September 1, 2020

3 Pilars of human life: Time - Energy - Vocation

No comments:

 

When we spoke about the universe in a previous article, we said that it could be reduced to time, space and matter/energy. These same elements constitute or are the pillars of our smaller universe: the human life. Bearing in mind that, as Einstein said, energy is a form of matter just as matter is a form of energy, we can define life as a continuum of transmutation between matter and energy, that is, energy that transforms into matter and matter that transforms into energy during a determined time and space.

The meaning of our life, that is, of this continuum of transmutation between energy and matter over a determined time, is given to us by a third factor: vocation. Someone has once said that the most important thing in life is not to reproduce but to produce, since even animals can reproduce. Vocation refers to this production; it gives meaning and justification to our living, and opens the door of eternity to us. Therefore, it links our temporality with eternity; however, we should not understand eternal life as an extension of time and space, but rather the absence of time and space.

When we speak about the beginning of the universe, we talk about the Big Bang that occurred on the day without a yesterday. With the Big Bang, time and space were created, which means that a reality existed before time and space – God. The third factor, vocation, has within it the meaning of our path, the way to Heaven on earth what we call happiness and the way to Heaven beyond time and space what we call eternity with God.

There are a countless number of books on spirituality that tell us that life is a gift from God. I do not deny that this is true; however, I prefer to look at life, especially at its spatial temporal stage, as a loan we have acquired from God. This loan consists of time, resources, materials or goods acquired or to be acquired, and spiritual resources, that is, talents that we are born with.

We are not the owners of our life, since we did nothing to have it, nor can we do anything to retain it. We are only stewards of the time we are given to live, of the place we occupy, of the material and spiritual resources that we have been entrusted with; of this stewardship, we will one day give an account to God who is the sole owner of our lives.

It is in this sense that the third factor, vocation, appears as the way by which our life will be productive, carrying out a project that will give it meaning in the here and now and beyond, leading us into eternity. A temporal life dedicated to the cultivation of human values leads to eternity, because human values are eternal, or timeless, they are unchanged by time, from one generation to another or by space, from one culture to another.

Without this third factor, human life as a gift would revolve around us instead; but since our life is not about us, it follows that it should not revolve around us, but rather around what we do with it, our vocation, our project, the gateway to self-fulfillment on earth and the conquest of Heaven.

TIME
Today’s man is strongly influenced by the spirituality of “presentism” which originated in the Far East, and by the philosophy of consumerism, which appeals more to our basic instincts and less to our reason, seeking to disconnect our acts in the present from their causes in the past and their consequences in the future. The goal is to lead man to live in a pseudo eternal present of a consumerist nirvana.

This philosophy can be good for the economy since it leads people to consume beyond their means as they can always borrow more money on their credit cards. The consequences of this philosophy are harmful to the health, but as these are faced only in the future, those who live only in the present do not care. It is a bit like the attitude of Karl Marx towards death: “this should not worry me,” he said, “for as long as I am, it (death) will not be, and when it is, I will not be.”

Surely life can only be lived in the present, as this is the only time when we are free to act and decide; the past can no longer be changed, and the future does not yet exist. However, the present is not only made of “present”, nor does the past refers only to the past and the future does not exist only in the future. The three times are interactive, and this interaction can only happen in the present, therefore the present is not only about what is happening right now, but also the meeting point of the other two, the past and the future.

Whoever lives in the present, disintegrated and with no reference to the past is a living dead: not possessing historical memory, he is a reed agitated by the wind, and as he does not know where he comes from, he does not know who he is, he has no identity. Whoever lives in the present, disintegrated and with no reference to the future lives without a dream, without a project, not knowing where he is going and, “for those who do not know where to go, there are no favorable winds.”

Whoever lives only in the future, loses many opportunities in the present and forgets that for this future to be possible, it must have one foot planted in the present. In other words, there are things in the present that must be done to prepare for the project to be completed in the future: if the future is the roof of the house, then the present is the foundations and walls. A future without a present is a utopia, a fantasy; it is like living in limbo, in an eternal “pause”.

Past
The further backward you can look, the farther forward you will see. Winston Churchill

The heritage of humanity is not made up only of historical monuments, but also of all that the human race is and has done over its 5 million years of existence on this planet. All of this is genetically incorporated inside the DNA of every child who comes into this world, it is something similar to Jung’s collective unconscious, it is part of us and defines us. All of this is the past.

“Libris ex libris fiunt”, when I want to create something new, in any field of knowledge, I have to research what has already been done in that field, and then I add to it my own research. Only God has the capacity to create from nothing.

Faith in the personal God, Creator of everything and everyone, who revealed himself through the prophets and then through his Son, who sent us the Holy Spirit, already has a history. My adherence to this faith makes me a part of this history, gives me an identity and a sense of belonging to a people and a community.

The same happens at an individual level: I know who I am and what I am capable of as I look back and see the performance of my talents and faults in the various circumstances that life has presented me throughout my personal history. It is the acceptance of this past that gives me the sense of self-esteem that I need so to relate properly with myself, with God, with others, and with my surroundings.

Even God, who lives in eternity outside of space and the flowing of time, to show himself to men, made use of his coexistence with them in the past, introducing himself to Moses as the God of Abraham, of Isaac and of Jacob.

Present
Unlike the past and the future, the present is in our hands, in it and only in it are we free to act. The present is the here and now of our life which must be full of action, work, charity and love. For a Christian, to live is to love and to love is to serve, to place oneself at the service of those most in need.

Putting into perspective what Mother Teresa of Calcutta used to do and how much there was to do in face of so much poverty and misery, a journalist once said to her, “What Mother does is like a drop of water in the ocean”, to which she answered with great humility, “yes, but if I didn’t do it, the ocean would have one drop of water less.”

God does not ask us to transform the whole world or to make it better, he only asks for our best. In the parable of the talents, the one who achieved the most was not praised more than the one who achieved less; in the parable of the labourers in the vineyard, those who worked the whole day did not receive more than those who worked for only one hour; in the parable of the sower, those that produced 100% were not exalted above those who produced 60% or those who produced only 30%.

Lots or little, all the Lord asks of us is that we bear fruit, that our life be productive: that we leave behind here more than we found, that we are part of the solution and not part of the problem, that is, that our living and acting be a contribution to solving the problems of this world and not a contribution to make them worse.

Future
Faced with the obstinate donkey that did not want to move, a young man tied a carrot to one end of a string and a stick to the other end. He then mounted the donkey and put the carrot two palms in front of the donkey’s nose. Hoping to take a bite of the carrot, the donkey kept walking, not realizing that the carrot was also moving.

Hope is faith on wheels, the dynamic faith that projects us into the future. We all need a “carrot” to keep going. Dream is the engine of life; in other words, what inspires our present is not in the present by itself.

Martin Luther King was one of those who, projected into the future, dedicated his life to the fight for equality between blacks and whites, a dream that he knew would not come to fruition in his lifetime. The day before his assassination, taking inspiration from Moses who after 40 years of walking through the desert saw the Promised Land in which he did not enter, and as if he were standing like Moses on the top of Mount Nebo, King said:

I just want to do God's will. And He's allowed me to go up to the mountain. And I've looked over. And I've seen the Promised Land. I may not get there with you. But I want you to know tonight, that we, as a people, will get to the Promised Land. And I'm happy, tonight. I'm not worried about anything. I'm not fearing any man. My eyes have seen the glory of the coming of the Lord.

One can only live with significance in the present if this present is impregnated with the future. Living in the present without the presence of the future is to drift aimlessly. And when the present is painful, it is the hope of a better future that helps us to bear it.

Conclusion – Human life results from a balanced and harmonious experience of the three times, among which it takes place. We live in the present and only in the present; but by looking back at the past we discover who we are and the meaning of our life; and by projecting ourselves into the future we find the motivation for our living. The present is just one piece of the puzzle that in its entirety includes the past and the future.

In the present of our lives, when faced with a decision to make, the past speaks of tradition, of our identity, of what we were as history, of what we are as identity, as a person. This past has, therefore, a word to say. For example, if I have reached the end of high school and I need to choose a profession, the past tells me that I am not good in mathematics so my profession must not be one where I have to study math all the time.

Faced with making this decision, the future also has a word to say. If the past tells me where I am, the future tells me where I want to be and the way to get there. “For those who have no sense of direction, don’t know where to go, there are no favorable winds”. In the present, I can ruin the future, which is why the future has a word to say in the present moment, since, contradicting another proverb, not all roads lead to Rome. If the future is a diploma in medicine, the present is hard work and intense studying to get there.

The biblical man – In Hebrew, the word “nikud” means, at the same time, both future and back, while the word “quedem” means both past and orient. Therefore, we can conclude that the biblical man has the past in front of him and the future on his back, that is, he walks with his face and chest facing the past, and with his back to the future.

With eyes on the past because that’s where our roots are, our being, our identity. We live walking towards the future, but we understand our life by looking at the past and with the past we are oriented towards the future. Of the future, we know little or nothing. That is why we walk backwards blindly; the only certainty we have of our future is death, but even that we don’t know how or when or where it will take place. For the pilgrim, the purpose of remembering or looking at the past is not to relive it, but to orient himself in the present, towards the future.

There is no evil that last forever nor good that never ends – We know that life has its ups and downs, like the line in an electrocardiogram or electroencephalogram. We know that on the way to God we can encounter heaven or hell, but we also know that everything is fleeting. So, when we are in the pinnacles of enthusiasm, we must not lose our head, and when we are in the pits of depression, we must not lose hope. At every moment, in every place, we live under the protection of the Lord, therefore we remain constant, patient and faithful.

  • The past is the reason, the present our action, the future our motivation.
  • The past is the tradition, the present the action, the future the innovation.
  • The past is what we were, the present what we are, the future what we will be.
  • The past is the being, the present the existing, the future the transcending.
  • The past is God the Father who created us out of love, the present is God the Son who saved and saves us, giving us health in the here and now, the future is God the Holy Spirit who animates, inspires and gives us strength in our journey.
  • The past is faith, the present charity, the future hope. 
3 attitudes towards time: fugitive – wanderer – pilgrim
Fugitive
And the Lord said, ‘What have you done? Listen; your brother’s blood is crying out to me from the ground! And now you are cursed from the ground, which has opened its mouth to receive your brother’s blood from your hand. When you till the ground, it will no longer yield to you its strength; you will be a fugitive and a wanderer on the earth.’ Genesis 4:10-12

What goes around comes around… Cain is a fugitive because he flees from a past that haunts him in the present. His journey is determined by his pursuers, not by him; that is why he has neither present nor future. He is trapped by something he has done in the past that is omnipresent in the form of remorse, in such a way that it denies him life.

Haunted by his past... It is an expression that denotes well the circumstances in which the fugitive lives. Like a hunted prey, he lives his life fearing being caught. The unresolved past issues haunt him in the present.

Passed waters do not move mills, but contradicting this law of nature, many people have their own mills, that is, their heads grinding with passed waters because they have not apologized or forgiven, or because they were traumatized or abused and have repressed these memories or they pretend that nothing has happened. They live in the past because their life or their present and future are determined by something that happened in the past.

They delude themselves, thinking that the past does not affect them because it is behind them. The truth is that what we know of our past, we can control; what we don’t know, controls us in an unconscious way. Therefore, by projecting the ghosts of the past into the present, we might think that we are fighting against our enemies when objectively we are only fighting windmills, like Don Quixote.

Wanderer
They live as if they will never die and die as if they had never lived. Dalai Lama

Carpe diem (Seize the day) – This became the motto of many people after the blockbuster film “Dead Poets Society”. The wanderer lives installed in the present, but not in the conscious and omniscient present of Eastern philosophies, but in a consumerist, hedonist and unconscious present, and as the expression has it: since we have to die let’s be merry while we live. Without caring for the past that has been and the future that is not yet and may never be, the wanderer walks in the vicious circle of an eternal return.

I make no promises so I won’t fail, we have heard this many times; the wanderer makes no promise to anyone nor does he commit himself to anything or anyone, because this would mean counting on the future. He lives only for the moment. In relation to the past and the future, he takes on the attitude of an ostrich: he buries his head in the sand, repressing and denying his own existence, preferring not to think, and to do this, he abstracts himself by using diversion or work as drug so not to think or face himself. Immersed in pure worldliness he does not need a guide, and takes advice from no one.

Pilgrim
Happy are those whose strength is in you, in whose heart are the highways to Zion. As they go through the valley of Baca they make it a place of springs; the early rain also covers it with pools. They go from strength to strength; the God of gods will be seen in Zion. Psalm 84:5-7

In the prehistory of our faith, there were countless pilgrimages: Abraham, a wandering Aramaean who owned only a grave site he bought for his wife and who traveled from his city in Mesopotamia to Canaan, the Hebrew people who left Egypt, the land of slavery, to the Promised Land of freedom and prosperity.

Examples of other pilgrimages are the journeys to Jerusalem for the Passover, and after Christ, the Christian pilgrimages to the Holy Land, Rome and Santiago de Compostela; in the Orthodox tradition, the Russian pilgrim has a book of orthodox spirituality; and in our times, the pilgrimages to Guadalupe in Mexico, Lourdes in France, Fatima in Portugal, Częstochowa in Poland.

A pilgrimage is a very important Christian practice because somehow it is a parable of life. To live is to go on pilgrimages, the Christian must behave like a pilgrim with the world around him and with his fellow men.

The book of Genesis does not hide the fact that God prefers the shepherd, and thus a nomad, Abel, over his brother Cain, the farmer thus a settler.  Unlike the fugitive, the pilgrim lives reconciled with his past, and therefore he does not depend on it; unlike the wanderer, he has a goal, a purpose that he intends to achieve, so he lives the present moment with intensity, always knowing who he is, where he comes from and where he is going. He is never bewildered or disoriented because his life is regulated as if he had a built-in GPS.

Egypt – Desert – Promised Land is the paradigm of humanity of a pilgrim. The pilgrim is always leaving an Egypt and always crossing a desert, and when he arrives at an oasis, he knows that it is not yet the Promised Land, and therefore he continues. The oasis of the Kingdom is already here, but not in its totality, as the Gospel says, and will never be in its totality on earth. For the pilgrim, to seek the kingdom, justice and peace are his main concerns, unlike for the wanderer.

ENERGY
Eros and Thanatos, the life and death instincts, affection and aggression, the yin and yang, the centripetal and centrifugal forces, love and hate, or the positive and negative poles of electricity are all terms to depict the types of energy with which we do everything we do. Without energy, nothing works in a society, and the same is true of us.

In the human being, all acts should be inspired and decided by the Logos, by reason; but the truth is that the instincts of Eros and Thanatos not only provide the energy to realize all acts that reason determines, but they also motivate, nourish and guide many others that subtract from the power of reason. Despite millions of years of evolution from animality, our behaviour is still motivated by instinct more than we would like to admit.

All human acts have a mixture of affection and aggression, even the most polarized, both in affectivity as in education and in aggressiveness as in war, there is always a little of the opposite pole; just as there is a bit of femininity in a man and a bit of masculinity in a woman. It is obvious that the rearing of a son by his parents has more affectivity than aggressiveness; however, an education that consists only of affection would have the tendency to be patronizing. In the education of a child, affectivity, rewards and caresses should be dosed with some aggressiveness, punishment and discipline.

Sublimation
The electric energy produced in a power plant, be it hydroelectric, nuclear or coal-fired, cannot be consumed directly. It has to go through a transformer to reduce it in such a way that it can be used in our homes. The same is true of raw human energy, common to both humans and animals.

In animals, nature takes care of the sublimation of Eros and Thanatos, so that these two energies are only at the service of life; animals mate only to reproduce, and for no other reason, not even for pleasure. They are aggressive when they need to eat or defend their territory, and not outside of these circumstances; they do not have, unlike some humans, the need to kill for pleasure.

In his book, Civilization and Its Discontents, Freud argues that both uncontrolled aggressiveness and affectivity, that is, abandoned to themselves have an immeasurable destructive potential. They can destroy what they helped to build. The human being abandoned animality when he gained power over these two forces, when he managed to domesticate them by harnessing their positive aspects.

In this way, the taboo of incest worked as the “halter” for Eros/affectivity/life instinct, prohibiting sexual relationships between people with close blood ties. Without this prohibition, ages of inbreeding would wipe out the human race. The rule of “eye for eye, tooth for tooth” (which belongs to the world’s oldest code of law, the Hammurabi code) worked as the “halter” for Thanatos/aggressiveness/death instinct, limiting the nature of violence that by itself tends to escalate and spread wildly, leading to destruction.

To sublimate means to divert, substitute or modify the natural expression of an impulse or instinct for an expression that is socially and culturally acceptable and constructive. An example of a destructive energy transformed into a constructive energy is the transformation of a bull used in bullfights into an ox that plows the land and pulls a cart.

Seeing things in this light, the human civilization can be considered as a history of sublimation of Eros and Thanatos, that is, of the intelligent use that humanity has made of these forces or basic instincts. In the same way, our own personal history is also made up of efforts to divert our natural affection and aggression from its natural and primordial target in order to promote the cultivation of human values.

VOCATION
To gain life or to lose life
For those who want to save their life will lose it, and those who lose their life for my sake will find it. For what will it profit them if they gain the whole world but forfeit their life? Or what will they give in return for their life? Matthew 16:25-26

It is often heard said about the one who works and walks in a constant hustle and bustle, running around “earning a living”. In this sense, earning a living is synonymous with a breadwinner; but to earn a livelihood and to live a life are not the same thing. Just as living and being alive are not the same thing.

Those who spend their lives (time and energy) seeking livelihood are different from the rest of living beings on this planet; the gazelles and lions, the tigers and leopards, or all the living beings except man spend their days searching for means to stay alive or to survive; animals do not live because they do not exercise any power or control over their own lives: they survive or simply are alive.

Unlike other living beings, human beings have the power and control over their own lives, they can do with it whatever they want; they can make it into a heaven or a hell, depending on how they manage the time and energy given to them.

Take care! Be on your guard against all kinds of greed; for one’s life does not consist in the abundance of possessions. (….) The land of a rich man produced abundantly. And he thought to himself: (...) You have ample goods laid up for many years; relax, eat, drink, be merry. But God said to him, “You fool! This very night your life is being demanded of you. And the things you have prepared, whose will they be?” So it is with those who store up treasures for themselves but are not rich towards God. Luke 12:15-17, 19-21

There are people who in their lifetime accumulated enough goods for two or three lives…, but are they going to gain these extra lives or even be able to extend this life after they have accumulated enough goods? No, life is not about earning a living. Life is not about fattening up but of thinning down, life is not about winning, but about losing; life is not a centripetal force, sweeping inward or to each of his own, but rather of centrifugal force, sharing, giving yourself to others for a cause. Therefore, anachronistically, life is lost when you keep it and is gained when you give it away.

Your life does not revolve around yourself, you were born for a mission
For the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life a ransom for many. Mark 10:45

For who is greater, the one who is at the table or the one who serves? Is it not the one at the table? But I am among you as one who serves. Luke 22:27

No one ever asked Jesus what was the purpose of his life, but if someone had, He would have given the answer above.

My life for others is an absolute value, but for myself it is a relative value; absolute for me is the reason why I live because my life does not revolve around me. If I were the reason for my own life, then living would mean surviving, that is, maintaining vital functions, or preserving life. But this is not true about human life; life is time, space and energy dedicated to a cause.

Beethoven’s life was focused on music; Picasso’s on painting, Einstein’s on physics, Nelson Mandela’s on equality between blacks and whites. The life of Jesus, the Son of God, was focused on the salvation of mankind. No one is happier than the one who is useful and no one is more useful than the one who loves and understands that to love is wanting and seeking the good of others.

All these people became famous, popular, heroes, eternal, because they spent their lives cultivating human values, like music, painting, social equality… As we’ve said before, human values are limitless in the space-time continuum, they transcend all places, cultures, and times; in other words, they are eternal.

So, when you spend your life, your temporality, cultivating eternal values, you attain eternity. Whereas, on the contrary, when you spend your life cultivating temporary values, like power or wealth, you are already cultivating death, and eventually when you die, that is the same as eternal death.

Talents are like the gifts of the Holy Spirit: they are directed not for your own personal fulfillment and gain, but to the service of the community. It is to the extent that you are useful to the community that you consider yourself valid within.

Talents, the tools of life
God who is the architect of our life has conceived a project for each one of us. No one comes into the world without a project. Through interaction with Him in prayer and in interpreting the signs of times, we must find out what project God has in mind for each one of us, and for which He has equipped us with enough talents to carry it out within the scope of a viable life.

Therefore, instead of envying other people’s talents, as teenagers do by covering the walls in their bedrooms with posters of “idols”, let us look at ourselves and discover what talents we have. There may be some hidden talent that we never thought we had… Just as the situation can create the thief, great challenges can create great men, when they push forward and risk it all. It is only by risking that they know whether or not they are up for the job.

Those who do not take risks do not gain: a talent that is not used is a talent that is hopelessly lost. Talents not found or used do not lead us to the purpose that God has set for us, and in not reaching this goal, our life has been futile. What has no use is garbage and what is garbage is burned – this is the meaning of hell.

3 attitudes towards space: settler – tourist – pilgrim
For here we have no lasting city, but we are looking for the city that is to come. Hebrews 13:14

If in the manner we relate to time we can be fugitives or wanderers, then in the manner we relate to space, the world around us, we can be settlers or tourists. Settlers, tourists and pilgrims have in common the fact that they do not come from the place they live in during their lifetime. They are different, however, in that they relate differently to the environment in which they live.

In other words, the settler as well as the tourist and the pilgrim are alike in that they are all from another place or country that is different from where they live in the here and now of their lives, but they differ from one another in the way they relate to the people and the world around them. People were created to be loved, things were created to be used. Only the pilgrim embodies this truth in his life, since the settler uses people and loves things, and the tourist uses both things and people.

Settlers
Veni vidi vincit, (I came, I saw, I conquered) as the conqueror Caesar Augustus would say. The settler comes to conquer and possess both people and things. He conquers and exploits everything and everyone without scruples, even the resources of the planet, it matters not to him the ecology. In this sense, he has the mentality of the donkey that said, “After I die, let there be no more grass growing on earth”. He also exploits others, regulating himself by the only rule he knows: profit and personal gain.

The settler came to stay, he has no plan to move on, and clings to things and people like a tick. He is sedentary, no longer seeking, no longer walking, and lives installed in life as if he has already reached the Promised Land. He enjoys everything that life has to offer him as if he were never going to die. God rejected Cain, a settler, and accepted Abel, a shepherd.

Tourists
Unlike the settler, the tourist lives superficially, since for him everything has the same value, things and people alike. He tries to amuse himself, and is not interested in owning anything or anyone, only the photos of everything and everyone he has collected. For the tourist, everything is a part of the landscape, the value of things is measured by the potential for fun or satisfaction of his five senses. Therefore, everything that is exotic, erotic, unusual and eccentric, and produces strong emotions and spews adrenaline is what is valuable to him.

The tourist does not penetrate into reality and sees the world as if it were a theater that entertains him, but he does not know nor cares to know what goes on behind the scenes. He doesn’t commit to anything or anyone, looks for distraction and runs away from anything that has to do with suffering.

Pilgrims
Once upon a time there was a man who would fetch water from the river every day with a bucket in each hand. One of the buckets had a hole in it so that when the man got home, there was only half of the water left in it. For this reason this faulty bucket felt sad, inferior and even ashamed in front of the other bucket. When it said this to its master, the latter smiled and said: "Have you not noticed that the path on your side is full of flowers and there are none on the other side? As I knew that your bucket was pierced, I sowed flowers on your side and you were in charge of watering them every day..."

The pilgrim does not own things or people like the settler, nor does he use and throw them away like the tourist; he is not installed in the here and now like the settler nor does he walk disinterested like the tourist. In his journey, he commits himself, giving himself totally to people and to concrete human causes, but as he does not try to be loved, but to love, he gives himself without being tied to the people he loves.

Many of the pilgrims of Santiago de Compostela were young and left behind music and joy wherever they went; the Portuguese language, the Galician-Portuguese, was born from these canticles about friend, love, mockery and swear words. On the other hand, the Portuguese Way to Santiago de Compostela is embellished with bridges and Romanesque churches and the French Way by churches and great Gothic cathedrals.

After Easter, it is customary in northern Portugal for the parish priest to visit one by one the families of his parish. It is a great feast for the members of the extended family who go to each other’s homes to kiss the Easter cross, the glorious cross of resurrection. For this occasion, people give an “Easter gift”, in money or goods, to the priest in recognition for his parish work throughout the year.

There was a priest in my town, Loriga, who received as much as he gave away, in the houses of the rich he received money which he then left in the houses of the poor; this was his Easter visit, he took from the rich and gave to the poor, thus contributing in this way, at least on one day the year, to the equality of Christians in his parish.

An American on pilgrim through the Holy Land visited the house of a rabbi, and spent some time in conversation with him. While they were talking, he noted that the rabbi lived in destitute, with only one bed where he sat and slept. At one point, the American asked, “Rabbi, where is your furniture?” and the rabbi answered with a question, “and where is yours?” “Mine? I am a pilgrim,” said the American. “So am I,” replied the rabbi.

God gives each one of us the time, energy, resources and talents so that life is viable and meaningful to ourselves and to those around us. Therefore, our self-fulfillment and happiness depend exclusively on us.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC

August 1, 2020

3 Roles in the Drama Triangle: Persecutor - Victim - Rescuer

No comments:
Sigmund Freud and many others after him have warned against the power of the unconscious in our daily lives. But even more serious than this is the realization that some of our behaviours, besides being unconscious, are so predictable that they blindly obey paradigms, as if we were a puppet. One of these paradigms is the so-called Karpman triangle.

The Karpman triangle or the Bermuda triangle
Since our goal is to explore and study the tridimensionality of reality, this psychological theory, which deals with the three basic roles that people play in the course of their interactions in a paradigmatic, predictable, uncritical and unconscious way, could not escape us.

In this triangle, each actor can play the role that best suits his personality; but the rules of the game and the situation created can force him to switch roles. In general, whoever enters this game plays all the roles and switches from one to the other, like a monkey jumping from branch to branch.

The peculiarity of this behaviour paradigm is that people who enter this dance or game, whatever may be the role they play in it (leaving it or remaining and continuing to play), end up getting hurt and hurting others. This is the reason why, personally, I call the Karpman triangle the Bermuda triangle.

The Bermuda triangle is an imaginary triangle between the islands of Bermuda, Florida and Puerto Rico where a significant number of planes and boats have mysteriously disappeared. The legend or popular belief attributes a paranormal activity to this space as the cause for these disappearances. This area is one of the most crossed by commercial boats, cruise ships and planes to which nothing seems to have happened. In other words, in the real Bermuda triangle no one gets lost, but in the Karpman triangle then yes, people who enter it do get lost; hence my mention of the initial belief.

Before explaining how the dialectic of this triangle works and proposing an alternative triangle, with alternative roles, so that people who have lost themselves in the game will find themselves and each other again, we need to explain the general and particular context where this theory comes from. The generic context is the theory of Transactional Analysis created by the Canadian psychoanalyst Eric Berne (1910-1970).

The most specific context in which Steve Karpman, a student of Eric Berne, bases his drama triangle is the psychological games that people inadvertently play with each other. It was Berne who studied this subject, having written about it in one of his most popular books, Games People Play. Instead of putting his name to this theory like many professors do even though it was deduced from his theory on games, Berne urged Karpman to publish it, which he did in a 1968 article.

Psychoanalysis
According to Sigmund Freud (1856-1939), our mind is divided into three different compartments that communicate with each other. We can also understand them as three beings with different functions that interact inside of our minds. These three entities are not of the same age: the first came already incorporated in the infant, the other two are only potentially existing.

ID – It is the oldest and consists of a set of tendencies, impulses and primordial instincts through which the baby seeks to satisfy its needs. The ID is more or less what we have in common with many living beings, especially those closest to us in the evolutionary ladder.

EGO – Through the child’s interaction with the world, especially with his primary caregivers during the first three years of life, the child learns that he does not live alone in the world and that the others with whom he lives and interacts also have needs and desires to satisfy. So, he realizes that in both the short and long term, it is not appropriate to be selfish and want everything for himself. Thus, EGO is born which seeks to satisfy the needs of ID, taking into account and considering reality, that is, the needs of others’ IDs. The EGO is the organized, operative, realistic and rational part of our mind.

SUPEREGO – It is the moral or ethical part that develops due to discipline, limitations, and moral and ethical restrictions placed by our caregivers. If EGO is the government of our mind then SUPEREGO is the law, constitution or ideology that the government follows; it represents the role of ambassador of culture or society in our psyche and is made up of the rules, norms, laws and moral values that we must respect and observe. The SUPEREGO is our moral conscience that at all times tells us what is good and should be done, and what is bad and should be avoided.

Transactional Analysis
Eric Berne who was a follower of Freud created his theory of Transactional Analysis by renaming the three valences of our personality according to Freud. He called the three valences ego states and renamed each one of them: the ID he gave the name of Child, the EGO Adult, and the SUPEREGO Parent.

Ego states – For Berne, this is a determined psychic pattern of feelings and experiences, directly related to a given behaviour. Let us see in practice how the ego states are processed:

Parent – A mother looking for a school for her child finds one where the students’ creativity is stimulated; however, on seeing the place, she judged it to be a bit dirty and disorganized, she concludes that it is not the right place for her child.

Adult – Moments later, she has second thoughts and decides to check the school’s ranking and to talk to some parents.

Child – In the end, smiling to herself, she exclaims, “How I wish my school had been like this!”

According to Berne, in a short time, this woman experienced the three different ego states: 
  • Child – Behaviours, thoughts and feelings reproduced from childhood. It is in the Child ego state that feelings, emotions and instincts are housed. The child represents the feeling in life. 
  • Adult – Behaviours and thoughts that are direct answers to the here and now. The Adult represents thoughts and reason in our lives. The reasoning, the analysis of data and information about a specific problem or issue, and the solution or resolution of it. It acts as if it were a computer, taking into account the child’s feelings and the cultural or ethical demands of the Parent, without being dominated by either the Child or the Parent. 
  • Parent – Behaviours and thoughts copied from the parents or caregivers. The Parent represents all that we have learned in our lives.
Later still, he sees that the Parent and the Child ego states must be divided into two sub-types for the sake of clarity:

PUNITIVE PARENT – Exerts power over others, controls, disciplines, pursues and punishes; represents the law, ethics and order. He/She is full of ideas, many of which are prejudiced, and in a traditional family, it represents our father.

NURTURING PARENT – Loving, affectionate, consoling who comforts, supports, protects and saves. In a traditional family, it represents our mother.

NATURAL CHILD – This is what remains of the ID, the part that resisted the rearing of the caregivers. It is represented by the angry, loving, impulsive, spontaneous or playful attitude of a person. The natural child is intuitive and full of energy.

ADAPTED CHILD – This is the natural child domesticated by education, less selfish than the Natural Child. However, when the rules were not assumed but only imposed, he/she is repressed, hypocritical and sometimes rebellious. The Adapted child is sometimes dominated by fear and shame.

Transactions
Berne calls structural analysis the inner dialogue between the different ego states and transactional analysis the dialogue we have with other people and the interaction between our ego states and their ego states. There are three types of transactions: complementary, crossed and ulterior.

Complementary transactions – When the answer comes from the ego state to which our question was directed. For example, when I say to someone “I love you” from my Natural Child ego state and that person answers “I love you too” from her Natural Child state.

Crossed transactions – When the answer comes from an ego state different from that to which we direct the question. For example, we arrive at work and say from our Adult ego state “good morning” to the boss, and he responds from his Punitive Parent state saying “you are late”. Or, using the previous example, when we say to someone “I like you” and that person answers “I know…”

Ulterior transactions – These occur when one person says one thing and means another. In other word, what you say is not really what you mean. Subterfuges are used, so that the real message is not in the lines but between the lines. Openly, the message is expressed from the Adult ego state, but the real message is hidden and must be deduced from the tone of voice used, words chosen and the body language.

For example, when everyone in the office has left, the boss asks the secretary to stay longer; but what he is really implying is that he wants to be alone with her. She answers that she is in no hurry, but deep down she is saying that she also wants to be alone with him. It is important to know what ulterior transactions are because all the games we play fall under this category of transactions.

The psychological games that people play
Games People Play was Eric Berne’s best-selling book. The book is basically a catalogue of the many games people play, with a description of how the game is played and what each player gets or thinks they get by playing it.

“Don’t play games with me” is a widely used expression. Therefore, almost everyone knows what a psychological game is. The idea already existed before Berne, but among all the psychological theories, his transactional analysis is the best one to explain what a psychological game is. Placing the games within the context of this theory, it is important to note that the protagonists of the games are always the Parent and the Child, without the knowledge or consent of the Adult.

This is why games are never beneficial to any of the participants, even when one of them apparently seems to be winning, as is the case of the sadist and masochist who seek and enter a relational dynamic where each seems to find what they are looking for. But this is an unhealthy relationship that only reinforces the disease and does not cure it. Psychological games are not activities where everyone wins, but rather where everyone loses.

Games are ulterior transactions, psychological tactics used to manipulate, control or intimidate others. For Berne, a psychological game is a set of ulterior transactions that take place in parallel at two levels: an open, social, Adult to Adult level, and a subliminal, covert or disguised level, with a dramatic outcome when the two levels coincide, that is, when the ulterior motives become clear. Let us look at an example:

“Why don’t you...? Yes, but...” – It is a game played between two or more people; one person presents a problem and the other a solution in the form of “Why don’t you…?” to which the presenter of the problem replies: “Yes, but…” The prize or reward of this game is the silence or masked opposition when the presenter of the solution exhausts his solution database. When this happen, the “Yes, but…” player is satisfied with being able to prove that the other is ultimately inadequate.

A - My husband insists on doing all the repairs at home, but he does nothing right.
B - Why doesn't he take a DIY course?
A - Yes, it is a good idea, but he doesn't have time.
B - Why don't you give him a good toolbox as a present?
A - Yes, but he won't know how to use them.
B - Why don't you hire a professional for the next repair that comes up?
A - Yes, but it will cost a lot.
B - Then why don't you just accept the way your husband does it?
A - Yes, but the thing is that sometimes the damage is even greater and it's all badly done.

At a social level, it seems to be a conversation between Adult A and Adult B, but subliminally or psychologically, player A acts from her insecure Child state and player B from her wise Parent state. After all, player A may even need advice, but since she rejects all of them, what she really wants is attention or affection. These are being given to her, but in an indirect manner so that the game will end in frustration for both, because this is not an adult way to ask for attention or affection.

Why do we play?
  1. The ultimate biological benefit of a game is to get attention or affection. Even if the games always end badly, all players get a fair amount of affection or attention, whether positive or negative.
  2. The ultimate social benefit of a game is the structuring of time. Thus, people fill their time with an exciting activity that could otherwise be boring and depressing. Games are a pastime, people are entertained by them, even when they end up getting hurt.
  3. The ultimate existential benefit of a game is how it confirms the existential position of each player. There are four positions:
I’m OK, you’re not OK (Existential positions of Rescuer and Persecutor)
You’re OK, I’m not OK (Existential position of Victim)
I’m not OK, you’re not OK (Existential position of Victim without hope)
I’m OK, you’re OK (Existential position of Adult)

Other reasons are:
  1. Not taking responsibility for our feelings, thoughts, behaviours or situations.
  2. To escape acceptance of reality as it is, by rationalizing or denying it.
  3. Running away from intimacy, but at the same time surreptitiously maintaining intense intimate relationships. The players do not empathize with each other because they are completely and unconsciously absorbed in the role they play in the game.
  4. Running away from internal conflicts and tensions, by projecting them out of us, dragging someone to take a role in our game. But the patterns and rules of the game make it impossible to solve any problem. The solution is never in the game, because it is the Adult that looks for dignified solutions and he does not participate in games.
  5. To make the other’s behaviour predictable in order to dominate him.
The difference between games and dramas is that in games people do not switch roles, there is a script and each person follows it, conforming to the role that he plays in it, and what he is trying to get out of it. In drama triangle, the roles are always the same three – Persecutor, Victim and Rescuer – and the players, actors or protagonists in the drama switch roles.

Drama triangle
The dynamics that are established around a person trapped by an addiction, which makes him depend on a substance or an obsessive and repetitive behaviour, illustrate well what are the particular dynamics of the Karpman’s drama triangle.

The dependent person, by playing the role of Victim of addiction, humiliation, prejudice, medical negligence and even police brutality, seeks and finds a Rescuer. The Rescuer plays this role by trying generously and altruistically to help the addict, without making sure that he is committed to the process of abandoning his addiction.

Frustrated in realizing that the Victim does nothing to get out of his addiction, the Rescuer becomes the Persecutor by accusing, insulting, neglecting or punishing the addict. The latter, seeing himself harassed in this way, strikes back and also takes on the role of Persecutor.

In this case, the game ends in violence, because in the triangle there cannot have two people playing the same role. If the game is played between husband and wife, it is likely that the first Persecutor will give in and, in the face of the persecution of the second, will become the Victim. This may lead the Persecutor that initiated the game to become the Rescuer, if we consider the Victim represents the addict. For example:

Adolf (Victim) – I want to quit smoking, but I can’t.
Eva (Rescuer) – I’ll help you, take these pills, I’ll get rid of the ashtrays around the house…

It turns out that the Victim is not really interested in quitting, he only wanted to please his wife so gave in to her, although he smokes in hiding. Eva finds out and from Rescuer she becomes Persecutor.

Eva (Persecutor) - "You scoundrel, coward, you asked me to help and I helped you, but you lied to me, you're weak, you'll never quit."
Adolf (Persecutor) - "I never wanted to quit, you made me with your nagging, go to hell!"
Eva (Victim - Rescuer) - She cries and feels guilty. After a while she returns to the scene as Rescuer saying, "Sorry, love. Can we start again? Here are other pills that are more effective than the first."
Adolf (Initial Victim) - "Okay, if that's what you want..."

A vicious circle starts again and the problem is never resolved. Adolf does not want to quit smoking and Eva does not accept him as a smoker.

PERSECUTOR
Normal – A cop chasing a delinquent or a father punishing his son who hit his younger brother, these are normal and common forms of persecution.
Psychological – A husband humiliating his wife when she decides she wants a job; an authoritarian and always severe teacher.

The Persecutor identifies clearly with the Punitive Parent of Transactional Analysis. He is an authoritarian, dictatorial, manipulated by fear, and prefers to be feared than to be loved. He also dictates the rules and enforces them without taking into consideration the will of others; he torments the weak, exploits their vulnerabilities, only see defects in others and exaggerates them.

The beneficial function of the father is to protect and provide for his family. The role of the Persecutor is a perversion of this function by trying to “reform” by force. It is known that every abused person becomes an abuser, every victim becomes a Persecutor: in order to avenge or distance himself from the harm done to him, he now applies that same evil on others who depend on him.

It is clear that in normal circumstances the Persecutor should be aware of the suffering he inflicts. However, he gets rid of the feeling of guilt by telling himself that what he does is for the good of others. It does not cross his mind that the ends do not justify the means. The methods used include preaching, blaming, interrogating, intimidating, attacking.

Just as the Rescuer wishes to “fix” someone, the Persecutor needs someone to blame! Persecutors deny their own limitations and defects, just as Rescuers deny their needs. The greatest fear of both is helplessness. In denying their own state of weakness, both have a constant need of someone on whom to project their own inadequacies. Both Rescuer and Persecutor need therefore a Victim to sustain their place in the triangle.

The Persecutor tends to compensate for his feelings of worthlessness by giving himself an air of grandeur. The grandiosity is inevitably generated by guilt. It compensates and disguises a great feeling of inferiority. Superiority is like moving directly from a “less than” to a “more than”.

The whole superiority complex is based on an uncomfortable feeling of inferiority; grandiosity is just a way to hide this feeling. The person begins by hiding it from others and ends up hiding it from himself, in such a way that he winds up believing in his own superiority.

Games of Persecutor
“Now I’ve got you, you S.O.B.” – This is used to justify the rage that has built up over an extended period of time. The aggressor (usually unaware) identifies the Victim, sets a trap and uses it as a way to take revenge or gain power over his opponent.

Experts in finding defects – The person seeks to find faults or limitations in others or in himself. He takes advantage of their faults to gain and exert power over them; when it is an auto-game, it serves to negatively reinforce his incapacities.

VICTIM
Normal – Someone who while crossing the street is run over by a drunk driver who did not respect the red traffic light; someone who is persecuted for religious, racial or sexual reasons.
Psychological – A wife who complains about her husband to everyone, but never makes a decision about the problem. Complains about addiction.

The victim state, from a psychological point of view, is just as sick as the other two. It is the person who never grows up, an eternal Peter Pan who enjoys and exploits the state of dependence on others. He externalizes his inner conflicts, attracting others to his problems and making them assume two roles, that of the Persecutor and the Rescuer. He needs someone to chase him, makes that person feel guilty, manipulates by guilt, makes others criticize, humiliate and hurt him. He continually sends subliminal messages that say “I am helpless, poor me”.

Both the way of being and the action of the Persecutor and the Rescuer create victims around them. However, the psychological Victim had an overprotective childhood by a paternalistic Rescuer. This is responsible for the Victim’s current immaturity, maladjustment and impotence: at the right time, instead of letting the child solve his own problems, the Rescuer solved them for him.

Formed and educated on the idea that they are intrinsically incapable, Victims adopt the “I can’t do it” attitude. This is their greatest fear, forcing them to always look for someone who is “more capable” to take care of them. Victims deny both their abilities to solve problems and their potential to generate power. They tend to see themselves as too fragile to take on life. Feeling helpless, exposed, mistreated, intrinsically bad and wrong, they see themselves as an “unsolvable problem”.

This does not prevent them, however, from being greatly resentful of their dependency. Victims end up feeling overwhelmed with being in an inferior position and try to find ways to fight back or “turn the table”. Moving to the position of Persecutor usually involves sabotaging efforts in order to save them.

Victims are expert players in the game “Yes, but…” described above. Whenever an advice, a suggestion or a solution is offered, the Victim responds with “Yes, but this will not work because…” Sometimes they take on the role of Persecutor as a way to blame and manipulate others into taking care of them.

Games of Victim
“If it weren’t for you…” – Often played between spouses and business partners as a means of avoiding responsibility for individual decisions.

Eternal debtor – Many times it becomes a script, a plan for the whole life. It is used as a means to achieve a goal in life; once this goal is achieved, the player feels depressed and aimless (goal), and starts a new game in search of the meaning of life.

“Look what you made me do” – Played by someone who feels hurt and angry, who gets involved in an activity that tends to isolate himself from people. When interrupted, in the event of an accident or error, he throws himself at the intruder, blaming him and making him a scapegoat of his own failure or for the accident that occurred.

“Let’s fight, you and him” – One player incites two others to fight each other and enjoys the fight as spectator and referee. The inciter stands on the winner’s side.

Wooden leg – This is used as an excuse for dysfunctional behaviour. “What do you expect from a person with a wooden leg?” Often used as a justification, that is, “I’m a redhead so I have a bad temper” or “I drink because I’m Irish”, etc.

“Give me a kick” – Played by people who feel the need to be punished; if they are not, they behave each time more provocatively until they exceed the limits, forcing some Persecutor to kick them; in this category are the abandoned, those who were fired, the rejected, etc.

Attraction/disgust – Played by people who are afraid of intimacy/closeness, but are also afraid of being alone. They try to seduce the other person and when that person is already seduced, the player backs off, leaving the person confused.

RESCUER
Normal – A doctor who preserves the life of a patient; the embassy that gives asylum to a political refugee.
Psychological – A mother who does her child’s housework; a therapist who systematically gives advice and does not help the client to think and solve his own problems.

In the same way that, in the traditional family, the Persecutor is the father figure, the Rescuer is the principle of the mother’s shadow. He looks at the other as an eternal indigent, helpless; he needs them to need him, and therefore the aid that is provided is meant to keep others dependent on him. The Victim is kept as a Victim so that the game does not end and he can even use blackmail and bribery to keep the roles going. He thinks he has a solution to all the problems.

It is the typical reaction of dependence that we call “suffocating”. It is a distorted version of the feminine trait of wanting to nurture and protect. Part of the problem with rescue is that it comes from an unconscious need to feel important or to establish oneself as the Rescuer. Caring for others is the only way that a Rescuer knows how to connect with them and to have self-worth. Rescuers generally grow up in families where they felt inferior and humiliated for having needs. They learn therefore to deny these needs by taking care of others. This makes it essential to have people depend on them.

Rescuers, deep down, are also Victims, that is, they recognize that they need to be cared for and that if they take care of others, then one day someone will take care of them. This becomes evident when the person they try to help rejects that help. In this case, they feel depressed and easily take on the role of Victim and martyr by saying, “This is what I get, after all I’ve done for you”, “No matter how much I do it is never enough” or “If you really loved me, you’d support me more”.

The biggest fear of the Rescuer is that no one will accept his help and care. He is unaware of the castrating dependency he projects when caring for those who depend on him. Through these tactics, he creates disabling messages. All those involved end up convincing themselves that the Victim is helpless, inadequate or defective, thus reinforcing the need for constant care. The job of the Rescuer then becomes to take care of the Victim, “for his own good”, of course.

Having a Victim to take care of is essential for the Rescuer to maintain the delusion of being superior and independent. This means that there will always be at least one person at the heart of each Rescuer’s life who is sick, weak, and unfit, and who needs his care.

Games of Rescuer
“I’m just trying to help…” – A future Rescuer is someone who is fixing the wound of a three-year old child who is protesting and trying to flee; when the child burst into tears, the future Rescuer raises her hands in desperation and says, “Damn it, I’m just trying to help!”

“What would you do without me?” – A teenager girl is babysitting her young brother and lets him out of her sight. When he screams in terror after having climbed a high chair, fallen and injured his nose, she runs, takes him on her lap and concludes “something always happens to you when I’m not around to take care of you”.

Drama in action
Mother (Persecutor) - If you don't clean up your room, there is no dinner for you.
Father (Rescuer) - Leave the boy alone, he must be tired, he was at school all day.
Mother (Victim) - I have been working all day too, do I have to do everything around the house?
Son (Saves the Mother, persecutes the Father) - Stay out of it, this is a matter between Mom and me.
Father (Victim in relation to the Mother and the Son) - I was just trying to help...
Father (Persecutor in relation to the Son) - You show me no respect, you cannot talk to your Father like that.

Another example:
Son (Persecutor) - You know I hate blue, and you went and bought me another blue shirt!
Mom (Victim) - I never do anything right in your eyes.
Dad (Rescues Mom, persecutes Son) - How dare you treat your mother like that? Go to your room and no dinner for you!
Son (Victim speaking to himself) - They tell me to say what I think, but when I do they don't like it.
Mom (Rescuer sneaks food to the Son) - We shouldn't have gotten so upset over a shirt.
Mom (Persecutor) – John, why are you so hard on our son? He must be hating you in his room.
Dad (Victim) - Darn it, I was only trying to help, is this what I get for taking your side?
Son (Rescuer of the Father, Persecutor of the Mother) - Oh Mom, stop it, can't you see that Dad is tired from work?

Solution for drama triangle
As we can see, games do not solve any problems but create others because they are perverted. The solution for the psychological games is to realize that we are playing them and call in the Adult to enter the process to stop them, forcing everyone to relate from the Adult position, abandoning the nurture or rescuer Parent, the punitive Parent or Persecutor, and the Child or Victim. Each one must take responsibility for his own feelings, thoughts and actions, as well as for everything that happens to him accidentally, and understand that this was not caused by others nor by bad luck.

More specifically in relation to the drama triangle, to combat each of the roles, several psychotherapists have created healthy alternative roles to play in a conscious adult game. The diagram illustrating this article alludes to these roles in the blue triangle.

No to the Persecutor, Yes to the Assertive – Instead of persecuting, one should be assertive, exhorting without punishing, encouraging self-knowledge and self-growth in others. Challenge but not impose, provoke or evoke action on others. Infuse hope and energy, fundamentally say to others “you can do it”.

No to the Victim, Yes to being Responsible – Accepting one’s vulnerability, limitations, without defending oneself of them, but say as St. Paul said, “when I’m weak, then I’m strong” (2 Corinthians 12:9-11). When a person is aware of his limitations, he is also aware of his capabilities and uses them, thus being the creator and protagonist of his own change, without passing the responsibility of his own life to a Persecutor or Rescuer. He strives for autonomy, looking for solution to his own problems and saying to himself “to want is to be able, I want, I am able”.

No to the Rescuer, Yes to being Empathetic – To come down empathetically to the level of the other person and, from then on, help in a non-moralistic way, without replacing the other but allowing the other to solve his own problems. This is the role of a non-directive psychotherapist according to Carl Rogers. He assists, supports, facilitates, asks exploratory questions so that the person sees all facets of his problem and helps him discover what he’s going to do and how he’s going to do it.

Rise and shine! No one is going to take the chestnuts out of the fire for you, not even God does for you what you can do for yourself. When no one sees himself as a Victim, the Persecutors and the Rescuers will disappear into the thin air, and friends take their places to help in the process of finding solutions for ourselves, helping us out of our misery.

Playing games is enticing others to act as victim, persecutor or rescuer in the drama of our immaturity.  However, if one of the actors decides to become an adult and relinquishes his role, the other two will eventually follow suit, and all will have an opportunity to grow up.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC







July 1, 2020

3 Stages in the Archetype of Progress: Egypt - Desert - Promised Land

No comments:
Archetype, model, pattern, or paradigm are synonyms that define the sort of reality which makes us conclude that history repeats itself. In other words, the perception of “dĂ©jĂ  vu”, like when we realize that we have seen before what we are seeing now. It is also what makes the metaphor possible, that is, a relationship of similarity between realities of different nature.

The validity and universality of archetypes, paradigms or patterns, as well as their usage and application in all facets of human life, are possible because human nature is always the same. It does not change in time or space, that is, it turns out to be the same in all generations, from Adam to our present day, and even to the end of time, and the same in all places on the planet, in all cultures and civilizations that have existed, exist or will exist.

We do not see in the exodus of the people of Israel from Egypt, in their passage through the desert and entry into the Promised Land, only one historical and theological reality but also the three stages of the archetype of progress in all its aspects – scientific, social, psychological, spiritual etc. – so that the reading of the biblical account appeals to our collective unconsciousness where, according to Jung, all archetypes are stored, which has the immaterial heritage of humanity and part of the cultural consciousness of the West.

The reading and analysis of this biblical account, beyond its historical and theological significance, can serve us as a guide and inspiration in other facets of human life that imply change, transcription, conversion, passage from one reality to another, growth and progress. Michael Walzer in his book, Exodus and Revolution, tells us that an exodus is a model or story that makes it possible to narrate other stories.

To be born and to die in light of the archetype
In light of this archetype, one of the events may be the process of our birth: we are confined in a very small place in our mother’s womb, attached to her like a patient to a life support system, without great freedom of movement and little space to grow. The passage of this type of “Egypt” into the Promised Land of freedom, the coming to light, is a process or passage that may be quick or take some time, but in both cases very painful and uncomfortable, both for the baby and for the mother.

If the entry into this world can be read in light of the archetype Egypt – Desert – Promised Land, then its departure can also be read in light of this same archetype. Towards the end of our lives, whether by old age or sickness and the suffering that it causes us, life itself becomes an unbearable Egypt.

We begin by having limitations in all kinds of things, we cannot eat this or that, cannot walk, become bedridden and finally, many are attached once again to an umbilical cord, that is, to a life support system that artificially does what some of our organs can no longer do naturally. Our life becomes an Egypt from which we want to free ourselves.

But to move on to the true Promised Land, the eternal life, we have to pass through the desert which is the process of death or birth into the eternal life. A process that is also painful, both for the one who experiences it and for those who are bound to the dying person by ties of affection.

When my late mother was in agony in the process of passing away, my father who was assisting her asked: “Do you want me to bring you the medicine?” – “No, I want to die.” And these were her last words. Faced with the hardship of the desert, but hopeful of the Promised Land of eternal life, my mother did not want to return to a life already full of limitations. Like she used to say, “I have already so many health issues, so many limitations and illnesses.”

The basic archetype of human life
“No pain, no gain” says the proverb. Once exiled from the earthly paradise, Adam and Eve know that this proverb, consciously or unconsciously inspired by the archetype, takes place in all aspects and strands of life and is already in itself one of the most important archetypes of human life.

We take as an example a young person who wants to become a doctor. Wanting to be a doctor is his vocation, his Promised Land; not being a doctor yet is his Egypt, because his true self at the moment does not coincide with what he ought to be, with what is in his being because he is not yet who he wants to be. In some way he has to stop being who he is and enter into a process that will take him to become a doctor: this process is the university attendance, to study every day.

Nobody lives in the desert; it is always a passing land. In the same way, no one is a student forever, being an applied student is a matter that lasts 7 or 8 years of his life, but which are indispensable for the acquisition of the degree that allows him to practice medicine.

In order to cross the desert, the Spanish people has two proverbs that advise us of the attitude to have towards the hardship of the desert. “Put on a good face in bad time”, although it refers to the weather, but it might as well apply to the difficulties that arise in our lives. In face of these, we must have a positive attitude, optimistic and not pessimistic or fatalistic.

“Take the bull by its horns” advises us that in face of difficulties, not to hide our heads in the sand, as they say ostriches do, an act that shows the common attitude of denial, not even to try to get around or escape difficulties, but to face them head on with a brave heart, with the willpower of a warrior, of a hero.

The very journey of the people from a past of slavery to a present of harsh penances and sacrifices, setting the sight on a bright, idyllic and utopian future, is an image of this archetype. The German Marxist philosopher Ernst Bloch based his principle of hope on Exodus.

This also inspired the black preachers of the sixties, such as Martin Luther King, as well as the political theology of Johann Baptist Metz, the theology of hope of Jürgen Moltmann, and lastly, the heir of these two, the Latin-American liberation theology of Gustavo Gutiérrez, Leonardo Boff and others.

History archetype
The Exodus constitutes the time of modern history, which no longer obeys cycles or myths but is an arrow travelling from the past towards the future. The time of history is a time where the past, the present and the future meet and dialogue with one another. The new is built upon what we have learned from past mistakes, and therefore not to remember the past is to be doomed to repeat it unconsciously, uncritically, indefinitely.

In keeping alive the memory of enslavement in Egypt prevents the same mistakes from being made. This is what the prophets did and what the apostles also did in their first evangelization discourses: to read the past in the present in order to guide and project the future.

Indeed, life itself is a pilgrimage as Hebrews (13:14) says – for here we have no lasting city, but we are looking for the city that is to come, and any concrete historical achievement of this is always only an image of the one that is always to come, and that is eternal life, because only in it do milk and honey flow unceasingly.

It sounds like the myth of the eternal return, but the same history tells us that concrete and historical realization of utopia, of the Promised Land, easily transforms itself over time into an Egypt from which it is necessary to leave again, repeating the experience of the desert. The true homeland and the end of all progress is life in God and with God.

Linear and cyclic conception of time
Cosmic time, the Circle – Starting from the objectively observable, the circular understanding of time has always prevailed in ancient Greece and the Far East. From the cosmic point of view, the 365 days that the earth takes to go around the sun, from the point of view of Nature, or more specifically from the changes in climate, the four seasons spring, summer, autumn and winter. From these facts, the myth of the “eternal return” was born to Philosophy, the idea that “there is nothing new under the sun” to Science, and the belief in “reincarnation” to Religion.

Human time, the Straight Line – From an existential and human point of view, each day that passes is one more day that we are going to live through and one less day that we have left to live. To conceive time as a straight line, which comes from the past, passes through the present and moves towards the future, is not something that can be observed in Nature.

Time in a straight line is the time of individual and community history, the time that integrates the idea of moral progress: today was better than yesterday, tomorrow will be better than today. In Philosophy, the Heraclitus’ saying that “we do not bathe twice in the waters of the same river” shares this understanding of time, and the same is true in Cosmology and Religion that convey the notions of the beginning and the end of the world.

This is also the Jewish conception of time: the departure from Egypt (land of slavery), the passage through the desert (land of suffering, penance, purification and effort) and the entry into the Promised Land, where milk and honey flow abundantly (land of freedom, rewarded effort and finished work).

Liberation, one social and one individual
Although the archetype, as we have said, can be applied to all kinds of evolution, progress, liberation, change or conversion, in this article we will study the biblical narrative of the epic of the Jewish people, from Egypt to the Promised Land, taking it as an archetype and therefore, as a guide and inspiration of two types of freedom: one social and the other individual.

For the social liberation, we chose Karl Marx’s theory, his historical and dialectical materialism applied to the analysis of a capitalist society and the offer of socialism as a solution to the problems of capitalism. In this sense, capitalism is the Egypt, the desert would be the dictatorship of the proletariat, and the Promised Land the classless society of socialism.

For the individual liberation, we chose the process the individual must follow to be free of any addictive behaviour, be it caused by a substance like drug, alcohol, tobacco, money or a repetitive and obsessive behaviour like sex, anger etc. The Egypt would be the addictive behaviour that keeps the individual deprived of his freedom, the desert would be the time of purification, detoxification and strengthening of the ego, and the Promised Land would be the regaining of freedom from the addictive behaviour.

EGYPT
Become aware that you are a slave
In the Bible, Egypt means knowledge and the love of knowledge. Egypt is, therefore, a place where you learn the truth. While Joseph ruled Egypt, it was a paradise for him, and his brothers and father. Psychologically, this means that while the mind dominates or governs the world, much can be learned. However, a pharaoh who had not known Joseph and the children of Israel, that is, the dominion of the mind over the physical world, began to reign in Egypt. The pharaoh represents the dominion of the physical world over the mind, or the dominion of the flesh over the spirit, as St. Paul puts it.

While the spirit or the mind has primacy or governs the body, its desires and appetites, the human being enjoys freedom because he is above all, a spiritual being. When, on other hand, the pharaoh rises to the throne, that is, the body with its desires dominate the mind and the spirit, the human being experiences slavery.

Egypt is synonymous with the land of slavery, but also at a later time, it is synonymous with the land of truth. I quote the story I told in the article about the tridimensionality of social action, See – Judge – Act: a Spanish priest with all his European baggage after having contemplated for some time the deplorable and miserable situation in which a community of Latin American peasants lived, asked them, “But are you not hungry and thirsty for justice?” They replied, “What is this hunger and thirst for justice? We, Father, only know the hunger for bread and the thirst for water.”

(Moses) looked this way and that, and seeing no one he killed the Egyptian and hid him in the sand. When he went out the next day, he saw two Hebrews fighting; and he said to the one who was in the wrong, ‘Why do you strike your fellow Hebrew?’ He answered, ‘Who made you a ruler and judge over us?’ Exodus 2:12-14

While the peasant only knows the hunger for bread and the thirst for water, he lives in a land of slavery, he is a slave without knowing he is one and, like the Jewish people when they lived enslaved, he does not accept that a Moses should come to speak about hunger and thirst for justice. The Hebrews also did not accept the freedom and struggle for justice that Moses offered.

Then the Lord said, ‘I have observed the misery of my people who are in Egypt; I have heard their cry on account of their taskmasters. Indeed, I know their sufferings, and I have come down to deliver them from the Egyptians, and to bring them up out of that land to a good and broad land, a land flowing with milk and honey, (…) The cry of the Israelites has now come to me; I have also seen how the Egyptians oppress them. Exodus 3:7-9

When the people finally opened their eyes to their true condition, then yes, they interpreted their life in another way, they began to be aware of being slaves in a foreign land and began to dream of another life in another land – a land that Jacob’s children had left. Now yes, they are ready to accept a leader to take them out of there, but also this is no longer the same Moses who had killed the Egyptian.

In line with the article “see – judge – act” which, as we have said, in its time was most likely inspired by the Exodus, after the people became aware of their life as slaves, an alternative to this life begins to surge in their minds. This alternative is a dream, a promise, an objective, a utopia situated somewhere in the future that acts like a magnet that draws the people to get out of their situation and walk towards the future where this utopia can become a reality.

Like a GPS, while the satellite does not discover the place that we are, it cannot tell us the route to the place where we want to go. And for those who do not know where to go, there are no favorable winds. The wind, or the driving force, only appears when we know our path, our goal, our utopia. After discovering this, it is time to leave, but before leaving, we celebrate our liberation, because hope will guide us.

I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia, the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slave owners will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood. I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character. Martin Luther King

Easter, the memorial celebration archetype
Tell the whole congregation of Israel that on the tenth of this month they are to take a lamb for each family, a lamb for each household. (…) You shall keep it until the fourteenth day of this month; then the whole assembled congregation of Israel shall slaughter it at twilight. (…) This day shall be a day of remembrance for you. You shall celebrate it as a festival to the Lord; throughout your generations you shall observe it as a perpetual ordinance. Exodus 12:3, 6, 14

A people who never gathers to celebrate their identity ceases to be a people. On each day of the ordinary time, each person dedicates himself to his task, work, and in this, he can be detached from the rest of his brothers. The whole nation, the entire people, or the whole association of people has days in which to celebrate their national or associative identity; if this ceases to happen, this people, this nation, or this association will cease to exist also.

God who is the creator of human nature knows it much better than humans. Therefore, even before the people left for the desert, he decreed that the same act of departure should be a celebration to be repeated in a ritual each year, so that no one would ever forget the price of freedom, how much this liberation from slavery costed.

Jesus came to bring deliverance to all mankind from all types of “Egypts” that deprive us of our freedom and dignity as children of God. And he also instituted a memorial act – the Eucharist – and explicitly said “do this in memory of me” after blessing the bread and wine that would become his body and blood, the price that he paid for our freedom.

DESERT
After the euphoria of the Passover celebration and the departure from Egypt, difficulties soon started to settle in: at the front appeared the Red Sea and from behind the powerful Egyptian army. The people, caught between the sword and the wall, felt the temptation to look at the dream which until then had led them on as if it were an illusion and a deception, like the mirages that precisely are well known in the desert.

This desperate situation was only one of the many that followed: hunger, thirst, serpents, plus the memory of the meat that they ate in Egypt now seemed like a dream but much more real and viable, because they had already experienced it. All this prevented them from marching forward, it seems now that the utopia has shifted from the future to the past. In the face of the challenges that freedom presented to them, the slavery of Egypt now appeared in their minds as a lost paradise. This explains the temptation to go back.

Freedom as a process
No bread without freedom and no freedom without bread. Bread is the food for the body, while freedom is the food for the soul. It is the soul that distinguishes us from the rest of the living beings. Therefore, the true human value is freedom and not bread, the ability to take our life into our own hands and make something out of it that is more important than life itself. However, to live, that is, to have life in our hands, we need to be alive, that is, we need to feed our body.

It is not edifying to sacrifice freedom to obtain bread, because we sacrifice our reason for life. It is like being humanly dead, like giving up life to be alive. Unless we sacrifice our freedom to get someone’s bread. Moses demanded from the people to temporarily give up bread, abundance of water and meat in exchange for freedom: a greater good than all these.

In assuming a new awareness of oneself, a new identity, to idealize and elaborate the project of a just and fraternal society in a way that freedom is synonymous with participation and responsibility for the project, is a long and tortuous path because the process takes time. In Moses’ case, the shortest and easiest process would be to go through the land of the Philistines, along the Mediterranean Sea.

Desert and detoxification
“We've got some difficult days ahead. But it really doesn't matter with me now, because I've been to the mountaintop. And I don't mind. Like anybody, I would like to live a long life. Longevity has its place. But I'm not concerned about that now.

I just want to do God's will. And He's allowed me to go up to the mountain. And I've looked over. And I've seen the Promised Land. I may not get there with you. But I want you to know tonight, that we, as a people, will get to the Promised Land!

And so I'm happy, tonight. I'm not worried about anything. I'm not fearing any man! My eyes have seen the glory of the coming of the Lord!!” Martin Luther King, the day before his assassination

Freedom is not conquered overnight, in one single act, in one flight. Freedom is a process with ups and downs, it is necessary to free ourselves from old habits, from the onions and the meat of Egypt, to overcome the temptation to turn back that arises when we encounter difficulties on the way; the desert means detoxification from vices and bad habits that enslave us. Cutting ties with the previous life in order to be available for the new one to come.

In the long process of liberation, many fell by the wayside. Moses did not enter into the Promised Land; Luther King who led the black people of the United States to freedom and equality also did not see his dream fulfilled in his short life.

Of those who left Egypt, only Joshua and his friend Caleb entered the Promised Land. They were both positive, always looking forward, were optimistic and did not fear what most feared. Especially in the episode of the spies of the land when fear paralyzed most of Israel’s children but Joshua and Caleb were there to infuse strength, courage, hope and faith in the God who had so often given them proofs of his love and dedication.

One cannot enter the Promised Land with the vices of the past, these have to stay in the desert. This is what probably symbolizes the fact that only two of those who came out of slavery entered the Promised Land, while the others who stayed on the path were succeeded by their children who had been born and raised free in the desert.

The lesson of the butterfly
A man spent hours watching a butterfly struggling to emerge from its cocoon. It managed to make a small hole, but its body was too large to get through it. After a long struggle, it appeared to be exhausted and remained absolutely still. The man decided to help the butterfly and, with a pair of scissors, he cut open the cocoon thus releasing the butterfly. However, the butterfly’s body was very small and wrinkled and its wings were all crumpled.

The man continued to watch, hoping that, at any moment, the butterfly would open its wings and fly away. Nothing happened. In fact, the butterfly spent the rest of its brief life dragging around its shrunken body and shriveled wings, incapable of flight. 

What the man, out of kindness and in his eagerness to help, had failed to understand was that the tight cocoon and the efforts that the butterfly had to make in order to squeeze out of that tiny hole were God’s way of training the butterfly and of strengthening its wings.

From outcasts to a people
A common enemy makes of strangers, friends. In the desert, everything is antagonistic and therefore, unity is strength – to survive, everyone’s effort is needed. It is not possible a direct passage from Egypt to the Promised Land, it is the desert that turns a band of outcasts into a people, with its own idiosyncrasy, law, language, way of life, common goal and a special relationship with God who walks with the people in the form of fire during the night and a cloud during the day, and who encamps with them, living in a tent.

This relationship of absolute dependence on God and interdependence on each other is later exalted by prophets as an idyllic time: “Thus says the Lord: I remember the devotion of your youth, your love as a bride, how you followed me in the wilderness, in a land not sown. Israel was holy to the Lord…” Jeremiah 2:2-3

The desert is not a place to live, it lacks everything, even the essential. Naturally, a person in the desert becomes more spiritual, turns to the inner landscape because there is nothing on the outside that captures his five senses. It is for this reason that for the people, the desert was a time of individual and social introspection and, within themselves, find the One of whom Saint Augustine says God is intimior intimo meo, who is inside of us and beyond our innermost self. In this process of introspection, two birds are killed with one stone: we get to know our very self and we get to know God who is inside of us but beyond our innermost self.

Alliance or pact
The transition from a state of oppression to a state of freedom presupposes an irrevocable change and an oath. During the march in the desert, the Hebrews guided by Moses made a covenant among themselves, as a people and with God. In this way, on Mount Sinai, a group of tribes becomes a people, a nation with laws and a constitution to govern their social life.

The difference from the earlier covenants with Abraham and Noah, which were unilateral and unconditional, is that this covenant with Moses is bilateral, that is, if the people remains faithful, God will keep his side of the oath. Moses gives the people the possibility of a choice.

“(...) this commandment that I am commanding you today is not too hard for you, nor is it too far away. (…) the word is very near to you; it is in your mouth and in your heart for you to observe. See, I have set before you today life and prosperity, death and adversity. If you obey the commandments of the Lord your God that I am commanding you today, by loving the Lord your God, walking in his ways, and observing his commandments, decrees, and ordinances, then you shall live and become numerous, and the LORD your God will bless you in the land that you are entering to possess.

But if your heart turns away and you do not hear, but are led astray to bow down to other gods and serve them, I declare to you today that you shall perish; you shall not live long in the land that you are crossing the Jordan to enter and possess. Deuteronomy 30: 11, 14-18

An identical discourse (Deuteronomy 31:1-29) is made by Joshua, Moses’ successor, before the last passage or Passover: that of the desert to the Promised Land by the crossing of the Jordan River. One more time and for the last time before beginning a new life in a new land, the people are reminded of the covenant that they made with God, which constituted them as a people, that is, which gave them an identity so often exalted in confrontation with other neighbouring or distant peoples.

THE PROMISED LAND
After crossing the Jordan River, the people finally reach the Promised Land, but this is not handed over to them with a kiss. It is said that God feeds the birds in the air, but does not bring the food to their nest, they have to go out and get it. It costed much to get to the Promised Land and upon arriving they come across Jericho, the oldest city in the ancient world and well-fortified. They then had to conquer it, like the rest of the land where milk and honey flow.

He went to evangelize and was evangelized
(…) as for the towns of these peoples that the Lord your God is giving you as an inheritance, you must not let anything that breathes remain alive. You shall annihilate them – the Hittites and the Amorites, the Canaanites and the Perizzites, the Hivites and the Jebusites – just as the Lord your God has commanded, so that they may not teach you to do all the abhorrent things that they do for their gods, and you thus sin against the Lord your God. Deuteronomy 20:16-18

I do not stop to justify or defend the verse with connotations of genocide, I leave this to the most learned in sacred scriptures. As we are speaking of archetypes, the symbolic meaning of this extermination that God ordered is not so much of the peoples but of the customs of these same peoples so that, as the same text says, it does not happen that the people instead of establishing their culture, idiosyncrasy and faith in the land, were to adopt customs, habits and vices of the peoples who inhabit that same land.

Therefore, it refers to a cultural cleansing, the kind of cleansing that Jesus did in the Temple of Jerusalem so that it would no longer be a place of business and idolatry, but a place of prayer and worship to the one God, the One who had taken the people out of Egypt and accompanied them all the way there, giving them this land. How many times we go to evangelize to bring others to our faith, our cause and end up being the ones conquered to their faith and their cause.

The fact that Joshua and his people did not obey God and did not exterminate all Canaanites including the women and children, does not mean that they were morally superior to God himself but rather that they did precisely what God feared: being the invaders, they let themselves be invaded and contaminated by the customs of the Canaanites and since they were no longer nomads, they also began to worship the gods of the sedentary peoples.

The Promised Land is the Kingdom of God
More than a concrete place, the Promised Land is individually a way of being who we are and the role we play in the world. We are in the world, but we are not of the world. The history of salvation began with Abraham, a wandering Aramean who left his land. Even before him, Yahweh did not hide his preference for nomadism over sedentarism. Without any reason other than this, he accepted the sacrifice of Abel who was a shepherd and therefore a nomad, and not that of Cain who was a farmer and therefore sedentary.

For this same reason, as we have seen before, the prophets exalt the time when the people walked through the desert, and condemn the sedentary lifestyle that leads to idolatry. God Yahweh is a god of nomads and not a sedentary god. The sedentary gods were gods of fertility, of agriculture. Sedentarism, to halt, goes against cosmic and human nature, because everything moves, we too have to be always on the move for when we stop and lower our guards, we easily become prey to idolatry. To be in the world without being of the world is an expression of a certain spiritual nomadism that we must maintain.

On the other hand, at the social level, we live committed to a project for a better world which is the Kingdom of God, but we never fully identify with any conquest, even in this sense.

The Kingdom is already among us since God through his Son (historically, Jesus of Nazareth) entered into human history. But the Kingdom is not among us in its fullness because the world can always be better. We know that it will never be like Heaven, the Kingdom of God par excellence. That is why we live committed, but not implicated or completely identified with the historical achievements of the Kingdom of God.

The Promised Land is not, therefore, a concrete geographic place but a society where justice and peace reign. And for it to reign, continuous efforts and constant vigilance are needed so that it does not descend into injustice and violence.

As we have seen, the Egypt of Joseph’s time was similar to the Promised Land, because Jacob’s children took refuge there with their father so that they would not die of starvation. During the time of Joseph, the adoptive father of Jesus, it became again a land of salvation, because it was there that the child Jesus took refuge until the death of Herod.

We can conclude that each Promised Land was once an Egypt and each Egypt can be a Promised Land. As Christians, we must live in the desert, always leaving Egypt and walking towards the Promised Land; today better than yesterday and tomorrow better than today.

The use of the archetype in Karl Marx’s communist theory
Karl Marx (1818-1883) was a German economist and philosopher of Jewish descent who lived in a time when the first social revolution emptied the countryside and filled cities with workers, including children, who lived in subhuman conditions, with too many hours of work, low wages, and in extreme poverty.

Capitalism is the Egypt of the proletariat
For Marx, society was divided into the proletarians, the new slaves, and the bourgeois, the new lords. He then applied this reading of the society of his time to the rest of history, which he saw as a class struggle in which the oppressed fight against their oppressor.

In this society, the capitalist bourgeoisie controlled the production process, whereby a factory’s products were sold at a price that included the raw material, labour and a profit from which only the bourgeoisie benefited. Some industrial philanthropists on realizing the exorbitant profits they enjoyed, distributed them to the workers, but most of them became ever richer while the proletarians became impoverished.

Like the Jewish people in their Egypt, Marx who was also a Jew understood that the resentment of the proletariat on seeing the fruit of their sweat stolen would increase until one day when the famous slogan of the communist manifesto of Marx and Engels (1848) would echo in all the factories: “Workers of the world, unite, you have nothing to lose but your chains.”

The dictatorship of the proletariat is the desert
With this, Marx understood, the proletarians would leave their Egypt, repudiate their condition as slaves and would take the reins of power and the production process. The roles would be reversed, just as in the parable of the rich man and the poor man Lazarus. (Luke 16:19-31)

These were the times of the communist revolution, difficult times for all, especially for the bourgeois who were expropriated from their power, property, and place and role they played in society. Their functions disappeared, their class disappeared.

Despite being an atheist, Marx applied to perfection the matrix of Egypt – Desert – Promised Land, and probably saw himself as the new Moses, who would bring out of slavery the new chosen people, the proletarians of the whole world.

Society without classes is the Promised Land
After the victory of the proletariat over the bourgeoisie and its capitalism, an instrument of oppression, a new society without classes should emerge, governed by Marx’s principle: “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs”. In this idyllic society, properties, lands, factories, means of production belong to all, are owned by all.

All would have the right and equal access to education, social classes would disappear, thus ending the dictatorship of the proletariat because there would be neither proletarians nor bourgeois, and harmony, justice and peace would reign that would make the state obsolete and eventually disappear.

Hegelian and Marxist dialectics
Most of us know that Marx drank from Hegel or, better said, from an inverted Hegel by his adoption of Feuerbach’s atheism. For the philosopher Hegel, the distinction between matter and spirit was illusory, and he concluded that matter was a form of spirit; Marx, on the other hand, understood that spirit was a form of matter.

If we replace spirit with energy (we can in fact understand spirit as an energy because they are both intangible), today we would say with Einstein that they were both right, matter is a form of energy, just as energy is a form of matter.

As an appendix, I would like to add a mention of the tridimensionality of Hegel’s dialectics, implied in Marx’s socialist theory. For both, history develops in conflicts between opposing forces: Thesis (Egypt), Antithesis (Desert), Synthesis (Promised Land). This applies to the class struggle, as Marx did, to nations, institutions, and so on until, in Hegel’s mind, we reach Heaven or, in Marx’s mind, to the classless society that would be, according to him, the end of history.

The use of the archetype in all sorts of fight against any form of addiction, bad habit or vice
Egypt – Desert – Promised Land is not only an archetype of social change but also an archetype of individual change, of conversion, of leaving behind some obsessive, compulsive, repetitive, neurotic behaviour that gives us the impression that we are living on autopilot and not on manual, of not being in command of our own lives and of being slaves to vices or bad habits, whether be in attitudes or in substances.

Time is late and we have no space here to develop the subject the way it deserves. In the course of our lives, we have fallen into situations of Egypt and lost our freedom before others, as in the case of domestic violence, through obsessive, compulsive and repetitive behaviours in the field of anger, sex and in many other fields. In the same way, we also lose our freedom when we become addicted to substances that end up playing a psychological or existential role in our lives.

Although traditionally used by the Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), the 12-Step program constitutes the main theory for dealing with all kinds of addiction, whether psychological or substance in nature. In our opinion, this theory also obeys the archetype and was drawn consciously or unconsciously on the basis of this paradigm that we have described.

The Egypt – Admitting that we have lost control of ourselves
This is the first step. While the Israelites did not realize that they were slaves under Pharaoh, the thirst for change to get out of this situation never arose. It is one thing to live in a situation, but another to know, to understand and to interpret that situation. Many addicts don’t see their situation as such; many smokers say that they can quit any time if they wanted to; one of them was heard to say anecdotally that it was easy to quit as he had done it 20 times already…

The Desert – Purification, detoxification, abstinence syndrome
The outcasts of Egypt had to constitute themselves as a people in order to survive together the hardships of the desert. The alcoholics anonymous are a community that comes together to fight an evil. Among the 12 Steps, some refer to this relationship that is established with others and with the Other, God.

The desert for the addicts is a place of detoxification. A liver takes time to detox, while the lungs can retain the accumulated pollutants for a long time. During this time of detoxification when the body starts to crave for the substance, the spirit while starving in the desert remembers the pots full of meat left behind in Egypt. The abstinence syndrome is the temptation to turn around and go back.

The Promised Land – Liberation, harmony, peace with oneself and with others
Finally, we arrive at the Promised Land, where we are once again masters of our destiny, where once again we have and can exercise control over our behaviour. According to the 12-Step theory, it is time to reconcile with those we have hurt when we were not ourselves and were possessed by the substances and behaviours that we can mystically understand as impure spirits. Once these spirits are cast out, we are free again and can relate in peace and harmony with ourselves and with others.

CONCLUSION
Both the individual change or conversion in the face of sin or vice, as well as the social revolution or evolution effort towards a society of justice and peace, follow this archetype.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC