One day, in a village, a woman presented herself before the parish priest claiming to have apparitions of God Himself. Wanting proof as to the authenticity of these apparitions, the priest said to her, "The next time God appears to you, ask him to tell you my sins, for he alone knows them." The woman returned a month later, and the priest asked her if she had seen God again; when she answered yes, he continued, "And did you ask him what I told you to say?" "Yes," she replied. "And what did he say?" "That he had already forgotten them."
... when he forgave us all our trespasses, erasing the record that stood against us with its legal demands. He set this aside, nailing it to the cross. Colossians 2:13-14
God forgives and forgets
"Annulled" can be said in two ways in Greek: "kiastrein" which means to cross an X over the invoice to invalidate it. Putting an X over something, however, does not prevent you from reading the invoice, so you can go back and consider it valid again. The word St. Paul uses "exalaifein", which means to erase. In those days, documents were written on goatskins with an ink that could be erased in order to reuse the skins. In other words, the invoice is permanently erased and it is no longer possible to read it anymore; therefore, there is not the slightest doubt of forgiveness. St. Paul stresses this idea further by adding that it has been destroyed: this is the meaning of nailing it to the cross.
If God forgives and forgets the offense of those who repent and ask for forgiveness, what is the use of Purgatory? God forgives and forgets; we sometimes forgive and forget the offenses of others; but we do not forgive or forget our own offenses so easily. Purgatory is the process by which we come to forgive ourselves.
In the classical theology sense, Christ has atoned for our sins, so we no longer need to atone for them; if on one hand, God forgives and forgets, then what is the use of Purgatory? It is we who do not forgive and forget the sins of others or our own sins; Purgatory is a requirement of our human nature. We see this in the gospel in the episode of Zacchaeus' conversion:
Zacchaeus stood there and said to the Lord, ‘Look, half of my possessions, Lord, I will give to the poor; and if I have defrauded anyone of anything, I will pay back four times as much’ (Luke 19:8). Jesus had already forgiven Zacchaeus, he did not demand anything from him in return as the price of that forgiveness; what Zacchaeus offered as reparation was out of his own free will as a consequence of his conversion and having obtained forgiveness, not as a requirement of it.
The same thing happens in the parable of the prodigal son (Luke 15:11-32): when the prodigal son repented, the boy brought a list of things he was going to do, as a reparation for his guilt; he resigned himself to losing the privilege of being a son and gladly taking on the role of a wage labourer, that is, to earn his bread by the sweat of his brow. When the Father saw him, he embraced him and did not give his son the chance to apologize; instead, he restored all the privileges of sonship, demanding no reparation from him, not demanding that he purge himself.
To the paralytic Jesus said, "Your sins are forgiven, stand up and go to your home" (Matthew 9:4-6). The woman caught in the act of adultery, after asking her if anyone had condemned her, Jesus told her, “Go your way, and from now on do not sin again” (John 8:3-11).
Whenever Jesus forgives, he does so unconditionally. He does not place any conditions, neither before nor after the forgiveness has been granted, he only gives the advice not to sin again. Doing penance as a reparation or purging of sin is a concept alien to Jesus during his public life.
Jesus dies as a lamb
In his view, from what we see in the gospels especially in the synoptics, Jesus, who was against the Temple and its sacrifices, did not see his death as a prerequisite for the forgiveness of the sins of humanity. However, this was how Mark and Matthew interpreted his death because they were Jews; but for Jesus himself and for Luke in his gospel, Jesus died like Socrates, as a consequence of having embraced, like a prophet, the cause of truth and justice.
God the Father did not demand that his Son die as a requirement for humanity's debt to be settled. This idea does not appear in any of Jesus’ parables or discourses. Jesus is not the "Lamb of God” under this interpretation.
However, at the last supper with his disciples, while celebrating the Hebrew Passover where the paschal lamb was sacrificed and eaten, it is likely that Jesus projected himself onto the slain lamb and the blood shed, and had, at the last moment, interpreted his death in the light of the Jewish Passover, as if he were a lamb, a scapegoat for the sins of humanity.
The subtlety of this idea lies in the fact that it is not the same to be the Lamb of God, destined and required by God the Father to atone for or purge the sins of humanity, and to interpret his death in the light of the Jewish tradition of the Passover meal, as an innocent lamb without blemish. Therefore, Jesus is not technically the "Lamb of God", but he died as if he were because he died like a lamb.
In His death, Jesus embodies the need of humanity to regain its self-esteem, to make up for the evil done and to make atonement for its sins. Again, this is not a requirement from God but a requirement from humanity itself. And since the second person of the Holy Trinity became human, united his own destiny with the one of humanity, thus also embodying the needs of humanity.
We do not forgive or forget
God loves us more than we love ourselves. We may come to love others unconditionally, but we hardly love ourselves unconditionally; we need to prove to ourselves our self worth; we get depressed when our lives do not go according to our plans, and we make negative judgments about ourselves. In this sense, Purgatory is a process through which we regain our self-esteem.
While playing ball on the street, I break my neighbor's window. My neighbor, who is a good friend of mine, tells me not to worry, that it is nothing. I accept my neighbor's forgiveness, but I do not feel good until I have replaced the broken window, until I have paid for the damage I caused. Purgatory is the process by which we compensate, counterbalance, and clear our debts.
Accustomed all our lives to living in the darkness of error and sin, when we stand before the face of God through death, we cannot bear the brightness of his light. So, for a moment, we avert our eyes to gradually get used to it. Purgatory is this process of purification and getting used to seeing God face to face.
We are saved by a holistic faith, that is, one that affirms God in our minds, loves him in our hearts and is faithful to him in our daily behavior and deeds (John 14:15). Conversely, it condemns us if we deny God in our minds, despise him or are indifferent to him in our hearts, living for ourselves and cultivating worldly values such as power, pleasure and wealth, without caring in the slightest for others or even being averse to them.
Most of us, if not all, find ourselves vitally in one of the thousand and one variations and gradations between these two opposites; we affirm or deny God partially, so that Purgatory completes what we left incomplete in life.
The condemnation of the person who affirms God in his or her heart and mind, but denies Him by the absence of acts of love of neighbor is just as biased as the condemnation of the person who denies God in his or her heart and mind, but affirms Him philanthropically in concrete acts of love of neighbor.
Both are incomplete, and in order to obtain salvation, they need to purge what they lacked on earth. Both salvation and damnation are holistic: by mind, heart, hands, that is, by thought, feeling, and deeds. Purgatory is for those who lack one or two of the three conditions for salvation.
Homo simul justus et peccator, said St. Augustine, and repeated by Luther many years later. Man in the process of perfecting himself, after accepting Christ as the Way, the Truth and the Life, is always progressing along the path of holiness, without ever completely overcoming sin. Purgatory is the complement that is still missing for perfection.
In the television series "Once Upon a Time", Purgatory is presented as a state of impasse in which the person who has recently died finds himself or herself. It is the same concept as a lost soul who is not yet in Heaven, but is not on earth either, having unfinished business on earth and with particular persons.
These people or "lost souls" need the help of the living. In the series, this help consists of a redemptive act, which must be carried out by a person from the deceased's inner circle and which has to do with the outstanding issue, sin or defect that the person manifested during his or her earthly life.
In the Church's tradition, this is called the communion of saints. The saints who already live with God in heaven intercede for us, who are still on earth and on our journey. We intercede for those who are in transition between earth and heaven, for the "souls in Purgatory", praying for them and offering Christ’s sacrifice for them in the Eucharist.
Conclusion – Purgatory is a provisional state for those who deny God partially; Hell is eternal death for those who deny Him completely.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC









