October 15, 2016

Conditioned forgiveness

No comments:
“… Forgive us our debts, as we also have forgiven our debtors. And do not bring us to the time of trial, but rescue us from the evil one. For if you forgive others their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you; but if you do not forgive others, neither will your Father forgive your trespasses.” (Matthew 6:12-15) 

God only forgives us if we forgive others
The Our Father is more than just a simple prayer. It is the most concise or the all-encompassing summary of Jesus’ message; it contains everything that we need to put into practice to have life and to have it abundantly. In Matthew’s version of the Lord’s Prayer, forgiveness is not only part of the body of the prayer but it also merited an added comment from Jesus as a “Post Scriptum”.

Of all the themes enumerated in this prayer, as if it were a list, Jesus commented on only one – forgiveness -- to make it clear, leaving no room for doubts or false interpretations, everything he has to say on this subject. This appendix addendum was presented in verses 14 and 15 which came, as we have said earlier, outside the body of the prayer.

In order to make people think, very often in my homilies I ask the congregation whether God loves us unconditionally, to which all unanimously answer ‘yes’; then I follow with the question of whether or not God also forgives us unconditionally, and without much thought they also all answer ‘yes’ because they think it is logical that this should be the case.

When I contradict this collective agreement that God forgives unconditionally by saying that unlike God’s love for us, his forgiveness is not unconditional, but rather that “some conditions do apply”, that it comes with some requirements. All are taken aback by that and many, again without much thought, are too quick to say that my doctrine is false.

Many Christians pray the Our Father prayer probably more than once a day yet are not fully aware of what they are saying and what the prayer demands of them. From the added comment that Jesus himself made, we can only conclude that despite loving us unconditionally, God does not forgive us unconditionally. Therefore we better satisfy His conditions first before asking for His forgiveness. In order for us to be forgiven for having offended God, it is “conditio sine qua non” that we should first forgive others who have offended us.

In fact, in the prayer that Jesus taught us, when we say, forgive us our trespasses as we forgive those who trespass against us, we are telling God that as we have already forgiven others, that is, we have already done our part, that He should now also do His part and forgive us in turn. We place the forgiveness that we should grant others as a pre-condition to the forgiveness that we ask from God; in other words, we ourselves see that forgiving others is the condition to receive God’s forgiveness for ourselves. What allows us morally to ask God for forgiveness is the fact that we have already forgiven from the heart those who have hurt us.

“…the measure you give will be the measure you get.” (Matthew 7:2). Just as the love we have for ourselves ought to be the same measure of love that we should have for our neighbours, we cannot wish to have God for ourselves and the devil for others. We cannot hope for God’s forgiveness if we do not truly and fully forgive those who have offended us.  This truth may be as hard to accept as was Jesus’ discourse on the Eucharist in the Gospel of John which caused many followers to desert the Lord.

And forgive us our trespasses in a greater way than we forgive others – As a matter of fact, the hardness of this language on forgiveness provoked similar dissent as that over the Eucharist; in recent time, the Brazilian charismatic priest Marcelo Rossi, giving deaf ears to the words of Jesus in verse 12 because of its hardness, replaced them with his own, as cited above.

Revoked pardon
Word of a king cannot be withdrawn – Let us recall the promise that King Herod made to the daughter of Herodias, and let us also recall the words of Pilate with respect to the words he wrote on the sign placed at the top of the Lord’s cross. A king does not go back on his word, on what he has said and promised. Much less God, the King of the Universe, would take back His word.

However, the parable of the Unforgiving Servant described in the Gospel of Matthew (18:23-35) suggests that on the subject of forgiveness, God can even go back on His word. The parable recounts the story of a slave who owed an exorbitant sum of money to his Lord who, having compassion on his slave, forgave him his debts. However, as this servant did not forgive someone who owed him a much smaller sum of money, the Lord took back his word and revoked the pardon that He had previously granted.

When God goes to the extent of taking back something that He has already given, something that a sensate person would never do, this shows how adamant God is about that single condition to obtain His forgiveness, that is, we must be ready to forgive those who need our forgiveness as much as we need God’s.

Allowances
“Then Peter came and said to him, ‘Lord, if another member of the church sins against me, how often should I forgive? As many as seven times?’ Jesus said to him, ‘Not seven times, but, I tell you, seventy-seven times.” (Matthew 18:21-22)

Always hitting on the same key, these are the verses prior to the parable that we quoted above where God withdrew the pardon He had previously given. God does not give us respite. We are to forgive and forgive not just once or twice but always, unceasingly and without getting tired just as God does with us. We can never say ‘enough is enough’ and we can never give up on someone because God never gives up on us.

Not taking anything away from the difficulty of forgiving someone who has hurt us, the following points can be of help:
  1. Take into account the person’s upbringing: the traumas suffered during infancy, the bad parents, the bad teachers. A perfect upbringing and education do not exist; since Freud, no one argues the effects that the first years of life have on the rest of our lives. To overcome these deterrents is not easy and many never succeed. In view of this, to what extent is a person responsible for what he does? If the courts of justice take into account these determinants then why don’t we also when we are called to forgive?

  2. Forgive them, Lord, for they know not what they do. This was the reason the Lord gave to forgive those who killed him. When we do evil things, most of the times we act under the influence of a powerful emotion; strong emotions fog up the mind the same way excessive alcohol does, and the person ends up not knowing what he says nor what he does. The prodigal son was out of his mind when he decided to abandon his family, as it was well told in the Gospel, and as the parable says, when he came to his senses he returned to his family.

  3. The sin is one thing, and the sinner is another. The person who commits a wrongdoing also does many good things but often we do not see the good, only the bad. Furthermore, it also happens that when a person who has always done right by us does one single bad thing against us, we end up condemning him forever for it. We report to the four winds the evil that someone has done, the good that this same person does not even in private do we acknowledge it; we criticize his wrongdoings and envy his goodness. Like God, we need to make the distinction between the sinner and the sin, so as not to “throw away the baby with the bathwater”.

  4. We are often hypocrites, criticizing others for the same wrongdoings that we ourselves do, or may one day come to do if given the same circumstances. If we can honestly conclude that we would do the same then to forgive is to put into practice the precept of the Lord that tells us, do to others whatever you would like others to do to you.

  5. But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you.  Matthew 5:44 – I would say that more than an exhortation or an advice, Jesus is giving us the technique that miraculously works. None of us like to pray for those who hate us, and yet, if we make the choice to do just that and commit ourselves to do what is right, going against our instincts, we will find that after some time the feeling of hatred starts to weaken and eventually disappears altogether. Give it a try and you will see for yourself. The Gospel cannot be wrong.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC

October 1, 2016

Forgive and Forget

No comments:
An ex-prisoner of a Nazi concentration camp was visiting a friend with whom he had shared this painful past experience. “Have you forgiven the Nazis for all they did to us?” he asked his friend. “Yes, I have,” his friend answered. “Well I haven’t and I never will, I still hate them to the depth of my soul.” Upon hearing this, his friend told him pleasantly, “If this is how it is, then you are still their prisoner.”

Like a computer with a large operating memory and without a hard disk to store the data, God forgives and forgets. For Him who lives in the eternal present, the past has no value. Along the path of life, both good and evil contributed to what we are today -- good works that shaped our good characters and bad choices that we made which dealt us invaluable life lessons because oftentimes we learn more from what we did wrong than what we did right. God is not interested in the particulars, however, but only in what we turned out to be today at this present moment.

“Up stream mills are not turned by passed waters”
Not to forgive is to choose to remain in a cell of bitterness, serving the sentence for the crime of another person. Mahatma Gandhi

God forgives, forgets, and turns the page. Just like the water that always flows freely and does not adhere to anything, so is God who does not hold any grudges. “Up stream mills are not turned by passed waters” says a proverb, but unfortunately, unlike God, the human mind defies this natural law. Many disturbances of the past keep turning inside of our hearts and minds in the present. Like an old scratched vinyl disc, the past is replayed over and over again in our head and is manifested in our behaviour.

A traumatic past is continuously and obsessively projected into the present, thus forcing the people in our present relations to play the roles of the monsters who have hurt us in the past, and making us react in the very same way we did then.

It is only by forgiving the people who have hurt us in the past that we are freed from the prison of resentment and other harmful emotions that are running loose inside of us -- and because we are not even aware of them, they control us instead of us controlling them. It is only when we truly forgive that we are completely set free from our past and all that went wrong with it. Furthermore, it is only by forgiving that the grip which otherwise they have on us is released.

It has been told that in Heaven Cain used to avoid the company of Abel until one day the latter not understanding the reason for his brother’s behaviour decided to confront him. “Hear me out, why are you running away from me? After all, aren’t we brothers?” Downcast and ashamed, Cain uneasily asked his brother, “Don’t you remember what happened down below on earth between you and me?” “I have a vague idea,” said Abel. “Was it you who killed me or was it I who killed you?”

For as long as the remorse lasts, the guilt also lasts. Cain had not yet forgiven himself… If God forgives and forgets, and turns the page, then for our own good and mental well-being we are called to do the same, forgive others as well as forgive ourselves.

It is true that the facts are not entirely forgotten from the cognitive point of view because God has endowed us with memory, but if we really succeed in forgiving then the hurtful facts are recalled in a different way, without emotion. They no longer cause us stress or anxiety, nor hate or resentment because they truly remain in the past and in some cases are even forgotten cognitively like Abel showed in the story.

Sin is a debt owed
…erasing the record that stood against us with its legal demands. He set this aside, nailing it to the cross. (Colossians 2:14)

“Forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors”, this verse comes from the Gospel of Matthew’s version of the Our Father. In the commonly recited form of this prayer, the word ‘trespass’ which replaces ‘debt’ does not confer the real biblical meaning of what is a sin or an offense.When we sin, we incur a debt against the one we have sinned; our relation with this person, that is, the order, the equilibrium and the harmony of this relationship are not restored until this debt is paid. This idea to satisfy, compensate or reward the one we have injured arises from the fact that we feel indebted to that person.

We need to regard sin as a debt owed in order to truly understand what St. Paul was telling the Christians in Colossus. He spoke to them in fact of an extensive invoice listing in great detail both the sins of mankind and their own sins. This bill which he described is a document of our debts, which by itself speaks against us because it reports all the evil that we have done.

In Christ, however, God the Father eliminated or cancelled this debt; in the original Greek text St. Paul does not use the term chiastrein which means to cancel by placing an X over the entire body of the invoice. He does not use this term because even after we cancel a bill, we can still read it again and afterwards maybe regret having forgiven the debt. Rather, the term that St. Paul uses is exalaifein, which means to delete.

In those days there were no papers, instead, they used and reused papyri and animal skins again and again. For this reason, they wrote with an ink that was easily erasable like we did until recently with chalk and blackboard. Once deleted, the bill can no longer be re-read. But so that there is not a single trace of such a bill left, God crucified it,that is, destroyed it completely as if it had been incinerated. It can no longer be re-read not only because it was deleted, but also because it simply no longer exists.

He himself bore our sins in his body on the cross, so that, free from sins,we might live for righteousness; by his wounds you have been healed.(1 Peter 2:24)

In taking on our sins, Jesus somehow embodied, that is, turned himself into the old Bill that contained all the sins or debts that mankind owed to God; by dying on the cross, he destroyed this bill forever. If in Jesus God forgives and forgets our sins,then we are also called to forgive and forget the sins of others as well as forgive ourselves for all the evil that we have brought onto ourselves.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC

September 15, 2016

Fatima: The first saturdays

No comments:
Sr. Lucia with the image she liked the most
When you see a night illumined by an unknown light, know that this is the great sign given you by God that he is about to punish the world for its crimes, by means of war, famine, and persecutions of the Church and of the Holy Father. To prevent this, I shall come to ask for the consecration of Russia to my Immaculate Heart, and the Communion of reparation on the First Saturdays. (Our Lady at the July 13, 1917, apparition)

The July 13th apparition was without a doubt the richest in content and also the most symbolic of the messages of Fatima. At this apparition, the three parts of the secret were revealed by Our Lady to the little shepherds, and it was also here that the Lady first spoke of the devotion of Five First Saturdays.

One of the reasons Lucia remained on earth and did not go to Heaven together with her cousins soon after the apparitions was to establish in the world devotion to the Immaculate Heart of Mary, and the practice of the first Saturday of five consecutive months.

Modus Operandi
Few years after the apparitions at Fatima, in 1925 to be precise, when Lucia was already a Dorothean sister, Our Lady appeared to her to remind her of the First Saturdays Devotion which she had requested in 1917. This time the Blessed Virgin told her in detail how it was to be observed.

Because some doubts arose in Lucia as to how it should be carried out, the Child Jesus appeared to her the following year on February 15, 1926, to enquire if she had already spread the devotion to His most holy Mother. At this same apparition, Lucia reported that oftentimes people were not able to find a confessor on the first Saturday, to which the Holy Child said that they could do the confession on any day of the month provided that they were in the state of grace on the first Saturday for the Communion of Reparation.

“Look, my daughter, at my Heart, surrounded with thorns with which ungrateful men pierce me every moment by their blasphemies and ingratitude. You at least try to console me and say that I promise to assist at the hour of death, with the graces necessary for salvation, all those who, on the first Saturday of five consecutive months, shall confess, receive Holy Communion, recite five decades of the Rosary, and keep me company for fifteen minutes while meditating on the fifteen mysteries of the Rosary, with the intention of making reparation to me.” (Our Lady in an apparition to Lucia in her room in Pontevedra on December 10th, 1925)

In order to understand why reparation needs to be made to the Heart of Mary, it is necessary to understand that the seriousness of an offense is proportional to the dignity of the person offended. It is not the same to offend a person on the street as to offend one’s own mother. The crime can be the same but the seriousness is much greater when it is perpetrated against one’s own mother. Saint Thomas Aquinas wrote in his Summa Theologica that the Virgin Mary, since she is the mother of God, has a certain dignity from the infinite good who is God.

The offenses against Our Lady are much more serious because the Virgin Mary stands at a different level from us all. The angels and the saints live in the order of Glory, because they see God face to face; we, on the other hand, if we live in friendship with God, are at the order of Grace. Mary by being the mother of Jesus who is divine participates in some way in the hypostatic union; therefore, the offenses against Our Lady are very serious because indirectly they are offenses made against God himself.

When Our Lady appears with her heart crowned with a crown of thorns like her son’s around his head, she wants to show in an easier to understand symbolic way how much she suffers from the “blasphemies and ingratitude” of men. If the son suffers then so does the mother.

Why does Our Lady ask us for this devotion of the five first Saturdays? It is because she understands the evil we inflict upon ourselves when we offend her heart. The Virgin Mary is glorious in Heaven, she can suffer no more; it is the feedback or the consequences of our offenses made against her that concern her. When a son hits his elderly father or mother the greater evil done by this son is not what was done to the father or mother, but what he did to himself; such terrible evil that if one day he becomes aware of it the remorse will surely consume him.

When a confessor of Sister Lucia asked her why five Saturdays and not seven, the perfect number in the Bible, Sister Lucia referred the question back to Our Lord who replied: “My daughter, the reason is simple, there are five types of offenses and blasphemies uttered against the Immaculate Heart of Mary:
  1. The blasphemies against the Immaculate Conception;
  2. Against her virginity;
  3. Against the divine maternity, denying, at the same time, to receive her as the Mother of all men;
  4. Those who publicly seek to infuse indifference, contempt, and even hatred in the hearts of children toward this Immaculate Mother;
  5. Those who directly outrage her sacred images.
Apart from some non-Christians, there are many Protestant Christians who offend Mary and among the Catholics there are some countries that commit the vice of blasphemy, like Italy and Spain. In Portugal, no one, not even atheists, or agnostics let alone Christians publicly blaspheme against God or against Mary.

Henceforth, these offenses have to be rectified, that is, the natural order of things has to be put back into its right place. To do this, we must perform four acts:  going to confession with the intention of making reparation or restitution, receiving communion made with the same intention, praying the holy Rosary, and spending fifteen minutes meditating on the mysteries of Jesus’ life.

Confession
In addition to being a personal confession of our own sins if we have them, and we always have them, this confession has another dimension: it is a devotional confession, that is, we make it for those who do not make them, and we ask forgiveness for the sins of others. It is once again the missionary dimension of Fatima, piety not only for our own sanctification, but also at the service of the sanctification of others.

The confession has to have a restorative intention; in the case this intention is forgotten, remember it at the next confession; it does not need to be made on a Saturday, it can be made on another day, as long as on the first Saturday of the month the person is in the state of Grace.

The Sacred Communion
“Very truly, I tell you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you.” (John 6:53)

Many Christians have abandoned the Sunday practice of going to Mass; and among those who still do, they have not for years considered themselves worthy to receive the body and blood of Our Lord. We make this Communion of Reparation not so much for ourselves, but for all those who are not joined with us in the Mystical Body, who are not in full communion with Christ and his Church, that is, the branches that are not abiding to the vine that is Christ. (John 15:5)

The Rosary
This is prayed with the intention of making reparation to the Immaculate Heart of Mary. We pray the Rosary for all those who do not pray it every day, and those who have not yet discovered the richness of this prayer, the time spent in contemplating on the mysteries of Christ in the history of our salvation.

Spend 15 minutes meditating on the 15 mysteries of the Rosary
These 15 minutes are spent being with the Lord contemplating on his mysteries, initially 15 and now 20. Since the meditation or contemplation is on the Lord, it can be done during the exposition of the Blessed Sacrament, it can also be a meditation of the Word of God such as Lectio Divina which nowadays many Christians practice; what is important is that we spend 15 minutes alone with Jesus hidden sacramentally in the tabernacle, and spiritually in our hearts.

The value of this Campaign
It is evident that both the offenses, as well as the acts of love for God, revert back to us. God does not need the good that we do for him nor does the evil that we do reach him. Both the evil as well as the good stay with the one who practices it. It is fundamentally we who bring evil upon ourselves, and God suffers not because of any evil that we do to him, but rather that this evil that we presumably do to him revert back to us. “The spell returns to the sorcerer” or “Whoever does evil, evil will happen to him”, says the people.

Many campaigns are made to awaken dormant values in the hope that once awakened it will continue with the help of certain practices. The campaigns are made to conquer the inertia, so that once on the move the hope is that it will continue on its own. This is what we observe in business practices when new products are advertised or if certain products are brought back into the market. The same logic works in religious practices; it is difficult to take people out of a mediocre life, immobility, and spiritual apathy, or as the Italians say, “doce fare niente”, which means sweet laziness.

In conversation with the Child Jesus at the apparition in Tuy on 15th of February, 1926, still on the subject of the first Saturdays, and why Lucia’s confessor had expressed certain reservations regarding the importance of this devotion:

“But my confessor said in the letter that this devotion is not lacking in the world, because there are many souls who receive You on the First Saturdays, in honour of Our Lady and of the Fifteen Mysteries of the Rosary.” (Lucia)

“It is true, my daughter, that many souls begin the First Saturdays, but few finish them, and those who do complete them do so in order to receive the graces that are promised thereby. It would please me more if they did Five with fervour and with the intention of making reparation to the Heart of your heavenly Mother, than if they did Fifteen, in a tepid and indifferent manner…” (Child Jesus)

In every campaign there has to be an appealing factor to take people out of their inertia. It is necessary to promise something in return; in this campaign, it is the promise of help, and that at the hour of death there will be all the graces necessary for salvation for those who are faithful to this devotion. But it is clear that God, as the Child Jesus pointed out to Sister Lucia, prefers those who practice this devotion for pure love and not for reasons of “spiritual commercialism”.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC

September 1, 2016

If Muhammad does not go to the mountain...

No comments:
To each their own – In human relations it is inevitable that conflicts arise, and the outcome of long heated discussions between individuals with different personalities and opposing views on the same topic are oftentimes quarrels and breaking off ties.

Quite often neither of the parties involved are aware of being offensive; in fact, both may even feel that they have been offended. This difference of opinion most likely occurs because both parties are accountable for being simultaneously the offender as well as the offended. As the saying goes, “it takes two hands to clap”.

In order to re-establish peace and harmony, the offender must ask for forgiveness while the one who was offended must be willing to forgive. When everyone does what they are supposed to do to restore communication, the quarrel ceases and a stronger and more lasting peace is reinstated between the parties.  They are now appeased even though initially they may have had to contradict and suppress their natural instincts and swallow their pride.

Easier said than done. In reality, this way of resolving arguments does not happen very often. On the contrary, too often the offender never asks for forgiveness and the one who was offended never pardons.

It is expected for Muhammad to go to the mountain
So when you are offering your gift at the altar, if you remember that your brother or sister has something against you, leave your gift there before the altar and go; first be reconciled to your brother or sister, and then come and offer your gift. (Matthew 5:23-24)

This Scripture passage asks the aggressors to recognize their fault and apologize. But if they fail to do so and in order to prevent a stalemate or a state where no one involved in the conflict makes a move, the Gospel exhorts the offended party to approach the guilty one. This situation is described in detail in the Gospel of Matthew (18:15-18).

In the Bible, one of the very first questions that God asks man is, “Where is your brother?” (Genesis 4:9), to which I cannot simply shrug and say that I do not know since I am not my brother’s keeper, as Cain did. If we seek to love our neighbour as ourselves we will then realize that we are indeed our brother’s keeper.

When we place ourselves before God, like the faithful in the passage of Matthew’s Gospel, He acts as a mirror and makes us see who we really are and how we relate to others. It is, therefore, impossible within this context not to recall the evil that we have done to our neighbour. If we ignore the voice of conscience prompting us to seek forgiveness from our brothers and sisters, then we are hypocrites; we can pray all we want and carry out all sorts of religious and pious practices but God will continue to turn His back on us for as long as we do not seek to reconcile with our neighbour.

The first commandment tells us to love God, the second to love our neighbour, but how can we love God whom we cannot see if we do not love our neighbour whom we can see (1 St. John 4:20)?  It is therefore only when we love our neighbour that we manifest and prove that we love God. This is presented in chapter 25 of the Gospel of Matthew: Whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did it for me…

The final judgment, as described in this chapter by the evangelist, touches upon the commandment of love of neighbour and not on love of God. So it is in a way a civil judgment and not a religious one. With this in mind, we can conclude therefore that any religious practices that do not lead to personal growth, to become a better person and to improve our relations with others, act like opium and lead to alienation.

Many Muhammads do not go to the mountain
When I was young I used to love to play with my cat and was always amazed by its agility. To put this to the test, I used to lift my cat up by its four paws and let it fall on its back but regardless of the distance to the ground, it was always able to turn itself around just in time and land on its four paws.

Very much like my cat, many offenders always land on their feet as they never admit that they have done anything bad and look for subtle ways to excuse themselves from any wrongdoings. They deceive themselves by rationalizing their bad behaviour, telling themselves that they did it without meaning to and that it was not done with any evil intentions. However much it costs some to admit, where there is smoke there is fire, i.e. where there is an offended there is an offender, and there is never an offense that is done for a good reason or for the good of the offended, but rather all to the contrary.

Time heals everything except old age and madness – Then there are those who know well enough that they are responsible and accept the fault, but because of their pride they reason that to apologize is to humiliate themselves before others so they hope that time will heal the wound of the one whom they have hurt. Psychology, however, teaches us that this is not what happens. When we ask for forgiveness the offense is removed; when we do not ask for it, the offense remains in the heart and mind of the one offended and probably building upon all the previous hurts, magnifying it and poisoning any future relationships.

Not to seek forgiveness is similar to a deep wound that for all intents and purposes appears to have healed externally because it closed so fast; however, internally the layer right beneath the surface begins to fester, generating pus and changing colour. Then when one least expects it, the wound erupts, creating a much messier situation than was originally intended.

Oftentimes we are astounded and left speechless when witnessing an episode of disproportionate outburst in the face of what seemed to be a small offense. What we didn’t realize is that this seemingly small offense is only the last drop needed to break down the dam of animistic resistance and the resilience of that person.

Be angry but do not sin; do not let the sun go down on your anger, and do not make room for the devil. (Ephesians 4:26-27) – As St. Paul suggests, it is better to always ask for forgiveness every time we sin and never let an occasion go by without doing it so that there is never a build-up of guilt and resentment.

What makes it difficult for some people to ask for forgiveness is the possibility of not receiving one in return, as well as the likelihood of having to face the anger and being humiliated by the person they have offended.

If Muhammad does not go to the mountain, then the mountain must come to Muhammad
If another member of the church sins against you, go and point out the fault when the two of you are alone. If the member listens to you, you have regained that one. But if you are not listened to, take one or two others along with you, so that every word may be confirmed by the evidence of two or three witnesses. If the member refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church… (Matthew 18:15-17)

If Muhammad does not go to the mountain, then the mountain must come to Muhammad – This is the most popular formulation of the old saying. Historically, however, the saying was first formulated the other way around, If the mountain will not come to Muhammad, then Muhammad must go to the mountain. This version first appeared in chapter 12 of Francis Bacon’s Essays published in 1625.

Perhaps making a reference to the Gospel of Mark (11:23) when Jesus told his followers that if they have faith they can move mountains, Muhammad made the people believe that he had the power to call a hill from the other side of the valley to himself and from the top of it offer his prayers for the observers of his law. Again and again, Muhammad called the hill to himself but the hill did not heed or obey so it remained standing still. Not feeling at all embarrassed or humiliated in front of his followers, Muhammad said unabashedly, “If the mountain will not come to Muhammad, then Muhammad must go to the mountain.”

In order to prevent a standstill, the calm before the storm, the Sargasso Sea of human relations, or the cold war, the Scripture above has something to say to the offenders as well as the offended. To the offenders, it urges them to seek forgiveness from whoever they have offended. In the event that they do not do so, and fail to fulfill their duty, then we, the offended, can and should forgive them in our hearts like Jesus did on top of the cross.

However, to forgive from our heart alone is not always enough and it is not instructional, neither for us the offended nor for them the offenders, because it is a passive behaviour.  The ideal reaction, in this case, is a proactive assertive behaviour: to go to the offender with a white flag hoisted as suggested by the Gospel passage above. First by ourselves, then with one other person preferably a friend of ours, and go as many times as needed gradually including more people, to give more weight to our cause.

When Jesus forgave his offenders from the cross, he did so in his heart alone because suspended on the cross he could do nothing else. At any other time, however, he showed us how to be proactive as when the servant of the high priest struck him on the face and despite being bound and surrounded by soldiers, Jesus asked the servant, “If I have spoken wrongly, testify to the wrong. But is I have spoken rightly, why do you strike me?”  (John 18:23).

We are not to approach the one who offended us with accusations, this would be an aggressive and counterproductive behaviour because faced with a verbal attack the natural tendency of everyone is to defend oneself. In the hope that our aggressor will take responsibility for his acts and therefore become remorseful on his own, all we can and should do in front of him who have offended us is to take on the responsibility for the consequence of his action; that is, to impart to our offender, not the harm that he did to us but the harm that we have suffered or are still suffering as a consequence.

As the Gospel suggests, when someone who has hurt us does not apologize, then to avoid a stalemate and a cold war of resentment we should go and confront him, not with his wrongdoings but with the pain and sorrow that he has caused. This denounces his offense more eloquently than our accusing voice would have and is infinitely more efficient in eliciting an apology from him.

Grammatically, the assertiveness although a proactive action uses the passive voice, in the hope that faced with our misery the one who has caused it would acknowledge his own fault, be merciful towards us, and ask us for forgiveness.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC

August 1, 2016

The Sun is setting in the West - Part 2

No comments:
The decline of a civilization means the appearance of a barbarian war-bands. And it is clear that, in one way or another, it is only a matter of time before the increasing senility of the countries that make up the Western world will see them succumb to invaders. The result will be the final extinction of the Western Civilization, along with its wealth and power, and a return to the Dark Ages. - Arnold Joseph Toynbee

The ineptitude of the political power
Following periods of absolute monarchy and republican fascism, the West is now becoming so used to democracy that it is taking it for granted, resulting in a general disinterest in politics. Like a runaway train without a conductor, Western countries are no longer masters of their own destinies, nor do they seem interested in reclaiming that role. On the one hand, it appears that they trust in their government too much, and on the other, they cannot be bothered with them because they believe the politicians do not actually rule on their behalf. In other words, the governing of the “Polis” (which means city in Greek) is no longer performed by the politicians.

In today’s world, the economy controls the politics, the markets control the economy, the finances control the markets, and the stock exchange controls the finances. The stock exchange is like a big Casino where money changes hands without ever producing wealth, each time concentrating into the hands of fewer and fewer individuals. This year of 2016, according to Oxfam International, 1% of this planet’s inhabitants possess more wealth than the remaining 99%; more precisely, this 1% owns 54% of the world’s wealth.

The public is somehow aware that some covert authority not easily identifiable is in fact in control and that the politicians are only puppets in the hands of the truly powerful who want to remain invisible, possibly because they fear for their own safety. As a result, the citizens have lost interest in electing their representatives because they know implicitly that whoever they elect will not be representing them but rather those CEOs and advisers of large multinational companies whom the people did not elect or know anything about.

The voter turnout for any given major election in the democratic West is in the range of fifty percent of eligible voters. In Portugal, the voter turnout was 46% in the last general election and 51% in the presidential election. It brings one to question the validity of these results when almost half, and in some cases more than half, of the eligible voters did not cast their votes. Before this political irresponsibility of so many citizens, would this not make a good case to make voting compulsory like in some countries? At least for a determined period of time as a teaching tool?

What was kept silent about the Bataclan
After having invoked and recited the Nicene Creed to the contrary: “I believe in one god the almighty Satan…”, at the very exact moment when the jihadists burst into the theater with machine guns, spraying bullets in all direction into the crowd, the American rock group the Eagles of Death Metal was in the middle of their performance singing a song pledging servitude and love to the devil. The fans were dancing and singing with the group, making the satanic ‘devil horns’ salute whom at the moment they were worshipping. The lyrics of the ‘song’ to the devil said: Who will love the devil? Who will sing his song? I’ll love the devil, I will kiss his tongue, I will kiss the devil on his tongue…

Despite the silence that political correctness imposed on this reality, some dared to observe the irony: they called upon the devil and he appeared. This is not, however, our interpretation because on that fateful night the terrorists’ targets were not only the Bataclan but also outside of Stade de France, the country’s national sports stadium, and in cafes and restaurants at random. Not all, therefore, were devil worshippers; many were there only to watch a soccer game or to have dinner with family and friends. No one deserved to die, not even the so-called devil worshippers if that was what they were and were not there just to have some fun.

There is absolutely no possible rationale that anyone can come up with to justify the actions of those Islamic terrorists. What makes me wonder, however, is why the young people at Bataclan and so many others have traded their rationally reasonable and plausible faith in the existence of God, and its revelation in Jesus of Nazareth - unquestionably the most perfect example of what it is to be human - for the superstitious belief of the devil’s existence, the personification of evil, violence, war and anarchy.

Like a reckless and rebellious infant, the Western world is biting the hand that feeds it. From any unbiased historian’s standpoint, it is undeniable that the Church, or Christianity, was and still is the “Mater et Magistra”, mother and teacher, of the Western culture. For all that the society tries to deny it, the values that the world calls civic values are the “copy and paste” of the Gospels.  There was, however, not a single mention of the Church, or of Christianity, in the European Constitution drafted by the ex-President of France, Valéry Giscard d’Estaing – did he do this out of ignorance or was it on purpose?

One piece of evidence which shows that the Church still influences the Western culture appears in the Principle of Subsidiarity which became the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and one of the principles of the European Union which was formally enshrined by the Maastricht Treaty in Article 5. The Subsidiarity Principle did not derive from politics but from the social doctrine of the Church, which appeared for the first time in the encyclical Quadragesimo Anno of Pope Pius XI in 1931.

Starting with France, then Europe and the rest of the Western World, the society is in decline because being surrounded by luxury, and living in abundance of pleasure and pure worldliness, it has lost its faith, the guiding star, the ideals of Christian humanism, the reason to live… going forward one can only expect the worst, as the saying goes, “To whoever does not know where to navigate, there are no favourable winds."

Here come the barbarians – with a new age of darkness
The evidence, unfortunately, is that the West is not even remotely interested in mounting a defense of its values in the face of Muslim fanaticism. Worse still, there are signs that the West is even prepared to sacrifice some of its core values in order to appease those who have always despised these values. – Lee Harris

In the 8th century when the Muslims invaded Europe, and what was left of the Roman Empire of the East Byzantium, they destroyed and took control of the holy places and prevented Christians from visiting them. The West had a strong moral at the time: inspired by the ideals of chivalry, the nobles were truly “noble”, and were ready to give their lives for values greater than their own existence. The Crusades were primarily a movement of legitimate defense of Christian ideals.

“Enough is enough”, we have overly apologised for what some of these knights did and are even trying to hide the very concept of the Crusade behind a taboo because the Crusade has been deemed to be not politically correct. There is no denying that there were some abuses of power and self-indulgences committed by the Crusaders which are not morally justifiable; however, the problem with political correctness is that by swinging in favor of the Islamic world, we only get to see the flaws of the Crusaders while concealing their virtues. The politically correct people forget that if it was not for the Crusaders at that time, today they themselves would be prostrating five times a day while facing Mecca at the call to prayer of the muezzin atop the minaret.

The grey matter of the West has abandoned humanism, that is, the philosophical and ethical thinking, and is completely self-absorbed in science and technology. Without ideals, the Western Civilization suffers from AIDS… in other words, from a cultural immunodeficiency syndrome which makes it an easy prey to Muslim fanatics, who even manage to recruit our own young people those who were both born and brought up in the West. Why are these youngsters so easily deceived by the negative ideals of fanaticism? The answer is quite simple, it is because they grew up in a world devoid of ideals. Worse than having negative ideals is not having any ideals at all. The West has forgotten that “having a good life” from the materialistic point of view is not enough. Humans, especially the young, need to know what to live for.

The teenage phase of personal growth is a time to dream of a better world; the young are naturally and instinctively idealistic. If the Western society of Christian origin, even if it disclaims it, no longer offers nor educates its youth in the ideals of Christian humanism, they will end up seeking some counterfeit ideals elsewhere. In fact, far too many of them are now running away from the so-called values and ideals of secularism that the Western society offers them to opt for the sort of fanaticism that the Islamic State are imposing instead.

The Islamic terrorism that has plagued the West in recent times is not the work of Muslims who come from abroad, but of our own young people who were born in our countries, grew up in our neighborhoods, and went to school and were formed in our universities, but they do not belong to us because they do not share our ideals.

No one gives up their life for the so-called “secular values”
The so-called secular values do not aspire the same motivating form of action and behaviour that religious values do, simply because no one gives their life for them. One evidence of this is seen by the choice of the cover of French satirical magazine Charlie Hebdo on the first anniversary of the massacre of some of its cartoonists, the January 6, 2016 issue.

On this cover, God is portrayed as an old man carrying a machine gun with blood on his hands and clothes. The special feature of this representation of God is that behind his head, with long hair and white beard, is a triangle that we all know as being the hallmark of the triune God of the Christian faith.

This portrayal of God is a cowardly criticism of the Muslim religious violence. The publishers of this magazine, who reserve for themselves the right to insult, throw the stone and then cowardly hide their hands behind their backs. They knew that they had nothing to fear from the Christians because we turn the other cheek. So it was easy and safe for them to use and abuse the “Christian God” in order to criticize the “Muslim God” and his followers.

It is very much like that employee who receives a slap on the face from his boss but unable to strike back for fear of losing his job, he slaps his wife when he gets home, and the latter slaps the oldest child in retaliation, who then slaps his younger sibling, who then slaps the dog or the cat.

When making the innocent God of the Christians as the scapegoat for the Muslim violence, the publishers of Charlie Hebdo made, inadvertently and ironically, a profession of faith in Him who indeed without guilt died for the sins of others -- Jesus of Nazareth. To Him they should thank for having helped them psychologically by absorbing innocently their rage that should have been directed at those who caused it, the Muslim fanatics.

Why is it that the nihilists, the atheists, the agnostics and those who live without God in pure worldliness, unlike the Christians, are not willing to give their lives for their ideologies and ethical values? The answer is simple. No one gives their life in exchange for nothing; Christians give their transient life for eternal life, while the nihilists as they have nothing with which to exchange it for cling selfishly and desperately to the only thing they have, a temporal life.

If these same groups were threatened with death to convert to Islam, as it was and is still happening to many Christians right now especially in the Middle East, it is likely they would convert in order to save their skins because it would be most unusual and almost ridiculous that they would exchange their life for the “nothing” in which they believe. In fact, to this day I have not heard of any martyr of atheism, agnosticism or nihilism.

This is precisely because no one is ready to give up their life for secular or nihilistic values, as it was proven by the cover of Charlie Hebdo magazine on January 6, 2016. Unlike when we stopped the invaders at Poitiers in the 8th century, this time we are hopelessly defenseless. Just like the Roman Empire was at the mercy of the barbarians in the 5th century… so are we now at the mercy of the new Huns, Vandals, Vikings and Visigoths, that is, the Muslim Fundamentalists.

Who will stop them this time at Poitiers if they are already within us like a Trojan horse and keep on advancing? Can we expect another landing in Normandy if America at that given time still remains Christian?

Reveling in false security, the West is so proud of its military might. For as long as the guns do not shoot on their own, the army continues to be primarily made up of young people who are becoming fewer and fewer in number in a West that is getting dangerously and progressively older.

The better solution to this problem was presented by the one who is presently perhaps the most influential politician in the world after the president of the United States, the German Chancellor Angela Merkel, the daughter of a pastor who said in response to the people regarding the potential Islamisation of Europe that instead of giving credit to conspiracy theories they should return to the Church and read the Bible like they used to.

The West should pay attention
All we wanted to say is that there are certain factors within the Western world that may cause its own collapse:
  • Moral degradation, lack of moral values and ideals to inspire and engage the young people
  • Lack of interest in politics as shown by electoral abstention
  • Low birth rates
  • Fragmentation of family
  • Extreme individualism, lack of sense of community and the common good
With these last two articles, it has not been my intention to be a prophet of doom and gloom. The prospect that history inexorably repeats itself is a sociological belief similar to predestination as a religious belief, it is not a principle nor a law of historical science. The role of the prophecy and its biblical meaning is not to guess what will inevitably happen, but to warn and prevent it from happening.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC

July 1, 2016

The Sun is setting in the West - Part I

No comments:
Civilizations die from suicide, not by murder. Arnold Joseph Toynbee

France as a social laboratory
The French Revolution is one of the many examples of how France, perhaps due to its geographic location, has been and continues to be the test tube of social ideologies which then influence the rest of Europe and eventually the rest of the Western world.

Would it be for this very reason that the same country that blocked the Islamic advancement into Europe, at Poitiers in 732 A.D., is now suffering from a new type of attack and invasion?  In the matter of a very short time, France was twice the victim of Islamic terrorism: in January 2015, against the satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo, and again in November of that same year throughout Paris, just outside of a sports stadium, in the city restaurants and bars and in the Bataclan theatre where a rock concert was underway.

With a view towards greater integration policies among member countries of the European Union, the former French President Valéry Giscard d'Estaing drafted the Constitution of the European Union. Approved by the Commission, it was destined to pass in all the parliaments of Europe had it not been defeated in a French referendum. After this defeat, Europe was never able to recover from the blow; today it is experiencing a profound identity crisis and a progressive disintegration.

For some time now this country has been the victim of a voracious, insolent, obscene and militant secularism, inspirer of the grotesque caricatures of the magazine Charlie Hebdo against Islamic and Christian faith, but never against the faith in atheism. Since the caricatures of Islam are well known because they triggered the notorious attack on the magazine, I point out two particularly shocking and blasphemous ones against the Christian faith: The Holy Trinity in a sexual “ménage à trois”, and Pope Francis being sodomized by a transvestite.

Despite the secularism and militant nihilism against religion, France is still a Catholic country as 63% of its population declare themselves as such. Once known as the “beloved daughter of the Church”, where is today the France that defended Christianity so well, and gave the Church and the world so many notable saints and theologians? Now downcast, it has lost its former glory and assertiveness, and in fear and shame allows itself to be vexed by unprincipled people, as if ashamed to be Christian.

Having been the country that stopped the advance of Muslims in the past, today it is the country in Europe with the most Muslims, making up 7.5% of its population, followed by Germany with 5.8%, England with 4.8%, Spain with 2.1%, and Portugal with 0.3%.

Can history repeat itself?
If history repeats itself, and the unexpected always happens, how incapable must Man be of learning from experience. – George Bernard Shaw

History is made not only of evolution and progress, but also of involution and regression. Since the time of Egypt of the pharaohs, to Mesopotamia, Israel, Greece, up to the time of Rome, each country, each empire made its contribution to the Western civilization which has been progressively developing economically, politically and culturally, until it reached its height in Greece and Rome.

From Egypt, we inherited medicine, astrology, and the origins of the written alphabet; from Mesopotamia-Babylonia, the first code of law -- the Hammurabi Code -- and agricultural techniques; from Israel, monotheism as the religious worldview and the Bible as the source of ethics; from Greece, philosophy, science, and democracy as a form of government; and from Rome, the Republic, the organization of the State, the law, the roads and the bridges.

It seems unfathomable that a superior culture in all aspects including military power could have succumbed to a bunch of uncultured barbarians coming from the North and East of Europe who plunged the continent into centuries of darkness. What caused the downfall of the Roman Empire? How could a superior culture be defeated and fall prey to a much inferior one?

As the renowned British historian Arnold Toynbee cited above, civilizations die from suicide not by murder. The barbarians only struck the final nail in the coffin; they only delivered the decisive deathblow to a civilization that had been dying for a long time. The Roman Empire ended by implosion. It fell on its own sword - it took its own life.

Rome was not built in a day nor did it collapse in a night. It was a gradual process that started with the moral degradation and decline of the civic values that had built the empire in the first place. It was the breakdown of the ideals, and the moral and ethical values which motivated and guided the day to day lives of the people. When these values disappeared, the lives of the people changed and with it, the society. Therefore, the morals, the ideals and the values which gave meaning to life in the Empire collapsed long before the Empire disintegrated politically, economically and militarily.

You cannot serve God and wealth. (Matthew. 6:24) – In the context of the Roman decline, God symbolizes the spiritual and authentically human values while money represents the temporal ones. Moral and human decline, as always, begins with the accumulation of wealth that makes possible a life of pleasure and luxury, thus creating the dissolute living of the ruling class.

From the ruling class, corruption spread like a wild fire to all levels of the Roman society. The lust for power led to political instability; the constant wars of succession forced the legions to abandon the defense of the borders to restore order and discipline inside of Rome. Furthermore, the increasing gap between the rich and the poor turned the Empire into a giant with feet of clay, a vulnerability that the barbarians were able to exploit.

Many factors which contributed to the decline of the Roman Empire, after 500 years of absolute dominance over the West, are now in progress in the Western world, making it even possible that history could repeat itself and that the adversaries, this time the Muslims, could cause the West to plunge into a second Middle or Dark Ages, as the American historians like to call it.

There were much fewer atrocities under the Caesaro-Papism (union of Church and State) rule of the Middle Ages than there are presently in the Sharia ruled countries. Some examples of their well-known atrocities are the bombings by the Afghanistan Taliban of the centuries-old statues of Buddha carved in rocks, the stoning of women caught in adultery in most Muslim countries, the cutting off of hands of those who steal, even if they were children, the dream of Erdogan, the President of Turkey, to restore the Ottoman Empire, the duplicity of Saudi Arabia as friend of the West while funding terrorism or any form of Islamic militancy, the dream of Iran to wipe Israel off the map and to possess atomic bomb, the atrocities of the Islamic State in beheading any opponents of Islam, even children for simply having missed prayer on Fridays…

The dysfunctionality of the family
As the germ cell of the family’s social fabric, family values are always the cornerstone of an ascending culture. This was true of the society in ancient Rome during its time of expansion and in the West just after World War II to the seventies. The real human and spiritual values thrive better in a frugal society than in one of abundance. In fact, it was noted that the increase in material excess that the consumer society brought to the West was proportional to the decrease in the living out the spiritual and human values. Furthermore, as it was also seen in the Roman society, gradually with each new generation the family unit began to fragment and weaken.

As in ancient Rome, starting with the decline of moral values, husbands and wives gave in to the compulsions of human nature and adultery became rampant. The number of failed marriages and dysfunctional families increased and divorce became the easiest solution to any types of marital conflict. Nowadays the divorce rate in the United States is at 53%, France at 55%, Spain at 61% and Portugal at 70%.

Unstructured and dysfunctional families resulted in more and more children and teenagers being institutionalized as the State has been forced to remove them from their negligent parents. In ancient Rome, the education of children and young people was carefully and painstakingly assimilated to instill the values of patriotism, the formation of character, the control of emotion, and the importance of obedience and respect for the laws. The same was true in the West up until the eighties.

Nowadays schools do not officially teach values; the only place where these were taught was in the subject called Religious and Moral Education, which has been eliminated from most schools. The few that still offer it to their students have downgraded its importance by slotting it at the end of an afternoon of spares, thus forcing even the most ardent students to give up.

A misguided concept and an inadequate application of “democracy” in the area of education have lured many parents into giving up their position of “authority” as educators for a position of equals with their kids thus pretending to be just their friends. This being so they have neglected to form and inform, and teach and discipline their children; instead, they are giving their kids more freedom than they are able to manage responsibly. The end result is that they grow up like little bourgeois with an easy and paved life that has made them weak, lazy, unprepared for life, irreverent, disobedient and living in a world of fantasy where they have only rights not duties, where they only consume without contributing.

With the loss of family values, the solidarity between generations is also lost. The proof of this is the growing isolation and loneliness in which many of our seniors live. Who does not remember the heat wave of August 2003 where in Paris alone 14,000 seniors died in their apartments. Many of the bodies were left unclaimed and therefore their funerals were paid by the State. Not even dogs die in this way in this day and age… ironically, in Portugal it is a crime to abandon a pet, but it is not a crime to abandon an elderly.

Negative birthrate
Recently on television a condom commercial showed a father shopping with his son inside a supermarket; on passing a shelf of potato chips the son grabs a bag and puts it in the shopping cart, the dad however takes the bag and puts it back on the shelf; the son defiantly grabs the bag again and puts it back inside the cart, the dad again removes it; after three times the child becomes hysterical and begins to kick the cart and the shelves until all the items fall to the ground. In the face of the expressionless father and adult onlookers watching the child screaming and getting completely out of control we hear the commercial message, “if you had used this condom (brand)… this would not have happened…

Any reasonable person watching this scene would conclude that the child is poorly disciplined; but the commercial wants the viewers to conclude that children are the result of failure of other brands of condom. The growing individualism and egocentrism in the West have influenced the birth rates; some married couples even contemplate the possibility of only getting pets in place of having children. Many of these pets are treated like family members, establishing with them the bonds appropriate with human beings; large fortunes are even spent on the welfare of these animals.

I recall the incident of a cat that was connected to a machine to keep it alive artificially. When the veterinarian recommended turning the machine off because its vital organs were no longer functioning, he was labelled cruel by the cat owner’s family.

The irrationality of abortion
Despite the population getting older and without enough offspring to replace the present generation, the West continues to legalize and perform abortion as a method of contraception. On this and other matters like the case of Galileo Galilei, the Church has been unjustly and wrongfully accused and stigmatised as being pre-scientific. In the case of Galileo, the reality is that he failed to provide credible evidence that could prove his theory; he was just not able to do so because it was scientifically impossible given what was available at the time. Similar situations occurred in regards to Einstein’s theory of relativity which only now can it be proven to some extent.

The truth of the matter is that the Church far from being opposed to has always been on the side of science, and some of her members are well-known leaders in their field of expertise; for example, the Belgium priest Georges Lemaitre developed the Big Bang theory, the monk Gregor Mendel is known as the Father of Genetics…

In the case of abortion, it is the society that places itself against science, because it is scientifically indisputable that human life begins at conception, that is, when the sperm, which is half of the human cell, unites irreversibly with the egg, the other half, approximately one hour after the conjugal act, forming a new human cell with an indivisible and unchangeable genetic code that is unique in the entire history of life on this planet. 

Once formed, the fertilized egg, the new being that is self-programmed, only needs to be left alone in the womb for nine months. To justify abortion some groups seek to redefine the beginning of human life at any other time after conception, doing so non-objectively in order to defend their ideology; outside the time frame of conception, any other time to which we allocate the beginning of human life will never ever be scientific, but rather arbitrary and at the service of an ideology.

While this is taking place in the West, Erdogan the President of Turkey whose dream as we have said before is the restoration of the Ottoman Empire, declares himself against family planning, birth limitation and gender equality saying that these are principles of Western ideology and are not applicable to the Muslim world; according to him, no one should interfere with the plans of Allah; the duty of a woman is to be a mother, the more children she has the better.

The function of prophecy
So Jonah set out and went to Nineveh, according to the word of the Lord. Now Nineveh was an exceedingly large city, a three days’ walk across. Jonah began to go into the city, going a day’s walk. And he cried out, “Forty days more, and Nineveh shall be overthrown!” Jonah 3:3-4

In the Bible a prophecy was never intended to be a prediction, but rather a reprimand or a warning: “If you continue to live in this or that way disaster will occur….” The people of Nineveh as we know converted after hearing the prophecy and what the prophet Jonah announced that was to come did not happen. The same can happen to the Western Civilization, by way of a revolution or evolution it can change its present course thus avoiding the decline towards which it is heading.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC

June 15, 2016

Seeking Forgiveness

No comments:
So when you are offering your gift at the altar, if you remember that your brother or sister has something against you, leave your gift there before the altar and go; first be reconciled to your brother or sister, and then come and offer your gift. (Matt. 5:23-24)

The word religion comes from the Latin religare meaning to relate. Christianity consists of two types of relation: to love God above everything and everyone, and to love our neighbours as we love ourselves. These two commandments are inseparable both in theory and in practice.

It is not possible to establish a relationship with God when I have broken relations with others. As long as I do not repair these broken relations with my neighbours, God will turn His back on me; therefore, all my efforts to relate with Him will be counterproductive, that is, my efforts to establish a relationship with God will amount to nothing as long as I am angry with my neighbours. Furthermore, to paraphrase St. John, how can you ask God for forgiveness whom you cannot see, if you do not ask for forgiveness from your neighbour whom you can see.

Inevitability of conflict in human relations
Conflicts are unavoidable in human relations. Conflicts divide people into aggressors and objects of aggression. In order for peace to be restored, the aggressors need to ask for forgiveness, while the ones who have been aggressed need to forgive. To forgive and to ask for forgiveness are therefore two sides of the same coin. This is because there are times when we are the aggressors and at others we are the objects of someone’s aggression, for throughout our lives there will be plenty of occasions for all of us to ask for forgiveness and to forgive. For some it is more difficult to forgive, for others, to ask for forgiveness.

When forgiveness is not asked for or granted, the aggressor and the aggressed cannot move on and end up tied to a past that both refuse to leave behind, resulting in the pair living in a condition of continuous present perfect, that is, in a state where the action that started in the past continues into the present.

Those who do not ask for or grant forgiveness hold a grudge forever. Something that has happened in the past at a particular place is happening again and again at all times and all places since the feelings felt there and then are still being felt here and now. The offender who has not asked for forgiveness is still offending and now not only the one whom he offended but also himself, since not having asked for forgiveness has made him a victim of his own pride. The offended who is not able to forgive, on the other hand, not only is still being offended but is also paying for something that he has not done.

Be angry but do not sin; do not let the sun go down on your anger, and do not make room for the devil. (Eph. 4:26-27)

An offense done in the past should have remained in the past; as St. Paul advises the Ephesians not to let even one day go by without interchanging forgiveness between the offender and the offended; and if we let one day go by then more likely a second day will also go by and then as St. Paul warns, we give an opportunity for evil to infest, as we start to nurse our grudge thus infecting the whole of our person.

When the offender and the offended do not take the responsibility to face each other in forgiveness, the offense nursed by both grows and drains them of their energy; it then becomes omnipresent in the mind and heart of the pair, hurting and bothersome like a pebble in the shoe. It places the two in an unstable climate of cold war with the possibility of an imminent conflict always likely to erupt.

To forgive and to forget
Oftentimes we hear the expression that the one who has not forgotten has not forgiven. In a way it is true if by not forgetting it means that we are still resentful and still holding a grudge. Does this mean that in order to really forgive, we have to have an amnesia of our past or have a sort of selective Alzheimer?

The answer lies in the different ways of remembering the offense; first, a forgiven offense comes less frequently to mind than an unforgiven one; second, a forgiven offense when it does come to mind does not generate the negative feelings it previously used to do, it acts now like a deactivated virus. It does not have the ability to evoke anger, hatred or resentment in the offended towards the offender. On the other hand, an unforgiven offense comes to mind often and every time it does, it makes the hatred and resentment grow in intensity.

The ball is in your court
“A thief believes that everyone is a thief” – Most offenders project their personality and capability over the ones they have offended and do not apologize because they are afraid of not being forgiven. Since the offense brings pain to both parties, and chains both to the past, each one should be made responsible for his own part in the conflict, and do what is expected of him to resolve it without being calculative about what the other one is doing to help the cause.

Our enemies are not those who hate us but rather those whom we hate – Most of the time the offended stops being angry at us the moment we ask for forgiveness and the relation is restored and oftentimes the friendship even grows deeper.

I know my offense, and recognize where I have failed like the prodigal son. I make the first move to apologize to the one I have offended. If that person forgives me then all is fine, but even if I am not forgiven, it is still equally okay; the ball is now in his court even if he refuses to forgive me; the stress, the anxiety and the remorse from the guilt that used to surround me disappears from my mind and heart because I have unloaded it and freed myself of it by doing what was required of me and what was within my reach. I cannot force the other person to forgive me; if he decides to stay in the past then he will be there alone without me.

To ask for forgiveness is not humiliating
For all who exalt themselves will be humbled, and those who humble themselves will be exalted. (Lk. 14:11) – Whoever admits his mistake and apologizes in a way is humbling himself, but this humility will surely lead to exaltation. However, whoever does not admit his mistake and does not apologize is acting out of pride, self-exaltation and arrogance which will surely lead to humiliation.

Oftentimes what prevent us from asking for forgiveness is the fear of being humiliated by the person we have offended, but in reality when we humble ourselves by apologizing for our offense we are placed in better light in the eyes of the person we offended.  On the other hand, when we do not admit to our mistakes and do not apologize we might feel good within the walls of our pride and arrogance, but in reality we look pathetic and are downgraded in the eyes of the person to whom we owe an apology. If we manage to put aside our natural feelings and embrace the reality, we will all be better off, more in peace and in harmony with both God and our neighbours.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC

June 1, 2016

Saints are those who see themselves as sinners

No comments:
Pope Francis making his confession
A Rabbi used to say that the sinners were closer to God than the righteous. And he explained it by saying that as a means of communication, there exists a thread that links our head to the hand of God. Each time we sin the thread breaks and as the result so does our communication with God. But each time we recognize our sin, and we repent, a knot is made to tie the broken threads together thus restoring the communication. When by chance we return to sin and again we repent, another knot is made; and as we keep sinning and repenting, the thread becomes every time shorter. In this way the Rabbi concluded, sinners are closer to God than the righteous.

The declared saints
The Church has a formal process that tends to be time consuming to declare someone a saint. First, responding to the petition of the faithful because of “fame of sanctity” of that particular person, the biography of the respective candidate is analyzed with a fine comb: virtues and flaws, writings, sermons, works. If the prospects are good, a postulator is appointed and the candidate is declared “Servant of God”.

The postulator then examines carefully the life of the candidate for sainthood and presents his conclusions to the Pope who declares the candidate “Venerable” meaning that the Servant of God lived the theological virtues of faith, hope and charity and the cardinal virtues of prudence, justice, fortitude, and temperance, in a heroic way.

Since the cause of beatification and canonization appears at times to be a tribunal case, beside the figure of the postulator stands the caricatured figure of “the devil’s advocate”. During the entire process, while the postulator finds ways to prove the virtues of the candidate, the devil’s advocate, who in our civil process is the district attorney or the prosecutor, seeks to remove the importance placed on the virtues by evidencing the flaws of the candidate.

The next step is beatification. If the candidate was a martyr, and has been sufficiently proven that he gave his life in defense of the faith, the pope declares him Blessed. If the candidate was not martyred then heaven must decide, that is, the postulator must present a miracle, which must be proven to have taken place through the intercession of the Venerable.

Lastly, the Blessed is declared Saint with the accreditation of a second miracle, which proves that the candidate is already enjoying the Beatific Vision. To him or her a feast day is assigned in the Church calendar, and he or she can be declared the patron saint of parish churches and the faithful can freely and without restriction, celebrate and honour the Saint.

The undeclared saints
“Not all those who live in a psychiatric residence are crazy and not all who are crazy live in a psychiatric residence”, says a Spanish proverb. After seeing how they have hastened some canonizations in recent times to satisfy the wishes or conveniences of some, I dare to use the same expression about the saints… not all who have been declared saints are indeed saints, and not all who are saints have been declared such.

There were, there are, and there will always be people who lived like saints without ever been noticed and declared such; for this reason, the Church created a solemn day to celebrate the never declared saints, that is, those whom the Eucharistic prayer refers to as those “whose faith and dedication to your service is well known”. They are given honour and veneration like the unknown soldiers of wars.

Saint is synonym for Christian
All the saints greet you, especially those of the emperor’s household. (Phil. 4:22)

To the saints and faithful brothers and sisters in Christ in Colossae: Grace to you and peace from God our Father. (Col. 1:2)

The disciples were called Christians, first in Antioch, says the book of The Acts of the Apostles. It was a name given by the outsiders, that is, by those who did not follow Christ and as such it was meant to have negative connotations associated with that name. “Christians” was not the name by which the early Christians were known. As we can see from the second text, Christians who were well known for treating each other as brothers and sisters in Christ were addressed as saints and faithful.

To call someone a saint when officially not yet true, according to the process described above, brings with it an implicit calling to sanctity. For this same reason we call Christians those who strive to be like Christ, such as St. Paul – when he said, “It is no longer I who live but Christ lives in me” (Gal. 2:20) – but it does not mean that they are already there.

Saints are those who recognize themselves as sinners
“He who stops wanting to be better, stops being good”. (St. Bernard)
There are two types of people: those who are not aware of their faults and do nothing to be better, and those who are aware of their faults and make efforts to be better every day.

Those who do nothing to improve themselves do not stay always the same, on the contrary, each day they become progressively worse. In the moral life, like in the nature, there is a law of gravity; whoever is not going up is coming down; whoever, aware of his imperfections, does nothing to be better each day, will not remain as he is but will go from bad to worse; whoever does not progress will regress.

When I lose the awareness that I am a sinner, then I am truly lost. St. Francis of Assisi, was perhaps the one person who came the closest to almost fully imitate Christ to the point of being called the “Alter Christus” and despite being in life already regarded as a great saint by his companions, he saw himself as a sinner and used to run down the streets of Assisi like a madman shouting, “I am a great sinner”. In fact, the truly wise judge themselves as ignorant, only the ignorant believe themselves to be wise; the true saints judge themselves as sinners, only some sinners believe they are saints.

I may have come far on the path of holiness, but what makes me grow even more, what makes me progress even more is to be able to find sins, defects, and imperfections in my life. For this, all I need is to refine my self-consciousness by making it sharper with the Gospel and surely I will always find something I need to change in myself. The true saints do not see themselves as such; on the contrary, they consider themselves sinners.

The true saints, after having converted from great sins, continually seek, in their conscience, other offenses that escape the examination of conscience of less holy people. They are really nitpicky in examining the bottom of their conscience, finding always something to accuse themselves, therefore they are always in a continuous process of conversion.

In the parable of the sower, the soil is to be blamed when nothing grows; a good soil is that which brings growth, it does not matter that it be 30% or 60% or 100%. What is important is that it produces, a bit or a lot, the quantity is of a lesser importance. We are not called to be the best, but we are called to give our best. Similarly, in the parable of the talents, what is important is not to hide the talent but to be accountable for it, the percentage of the profit being secondary.

homo simul iustus et peccator – On the path to sanctity the human person is and will always be both a saint and a sinner at the same time. To be holy is to walk on this path where today we are better than we were yesterday but not as good as we will be tomorrow. More than a state of being or a goal, to be holy is a process of perfection impelled and motivated by the ever presence of our consciousness of being a sinner.
Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC

May 15, 2016

To Be and Ought-To-Be

No comments:
Why do you see the speck in your neighbour’s eye, but do not notice the log in your own eye? Or how can you say to your neighbour, “Let me take the speck out of your eye”, while the log is in your own eye? You hypocrite, first take the log out of your own eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your neighbour’s eye. (Matt. 7:3-5)

To criticize others is almost always a negative thing; the so called “constructive criticism” is nothing more than an opportunity, unconscious and subvert, to rebuke and humiliate someone while exalting ourselves; in fact, whenever we demean someone we exalt ourselves, and whenever we praise ourselves we demean someone. There is an implicit humiliation in all exaltations.

The one in contradiction with you could be a great friend, deliver yourself from those who always agree with you.  (António Aleixo)

What distinguishes a negative criticism from a positive one is the proven friendship that we have with the person whom we criticize. We only have the “right” to criticize someone we love and whose values we recognize. And even then, the criticism can only come after an affirmation of those merits. So if we neither recognize nor affirm them in that person, we have no right to criticize him or her, and if we still choose to do so, the criticism will most probably be negative.

The general psychosis of our days
Without self-consciousness we do not know ourselves, and without self-criticism there is neither personal growth nor progress. As it has been said above, if on the one hand, it is almost always negative to criticize others, then on the other hand, it is almost always positive to criticize oneself. What we are and what we ought to be are never the same; it is the awareness of this reality that impels us to grow and to progress in life.

“Love is like the moon, when it is not increasing in brightness and size, it is decreasing” – Placed on a moving planet, we must be aware that at the physical level nothing in the reality that surrounds us and what forms our being is static. The same happens at the spiritual and moral level. When we are not striving to be better, we will decline and become worse and worse

To live is like flying in an airplane; without the thrust of the engines to maintain the altitude or to climb higher, we inevitably descend; there is no inertia or a law of gravity to propel us upwards, for it always pushes us downwards. Automatically, without effort and without consciousness, we always do what our animal nature dictates to us through instincts, which is almost always bad both at the personal as well as at the social level.

The death of conscience
For John had been telling Herod, ‘It is not lawful for you to have your brother’s wife.’ And Herodias had a grudge against him, and wanted to kill him. But she could not, for Herod feared John, knowing that he was a righteous and holy man, and he protected him. When he heard him, he was greatly perplexed, and yet he liked to listen to him. (…) Herod on his birthday gave a banquet (...). When his daughter Herodias came in and danced, she pleased Herod and his guests; and the king said to the girl, “Ask me for whatever you wish (…) ‘I want you to give me at once the head of John the Baptist on a platter.’ (Mk. 6:18-25)

He who does not live the way he thinks, ends up thinking the way he lives – Whoever, despite the effort to be better, fails to adapt his life, his actions and his behaviour to the dictates of his moral conscience, will end up adjusting his moral conscience to the reality of his life, and thus justifying and rationalizing his actions and behaviour.

In order to preserve the person’s mental health, the battle cannot continue indefinitely. Too much time spent on indecisiveness will drive the individual to neurosis; he either adapts his way of living to his moral values, or adapts his moral values to his way of living. Whoever cannot adapt his life to his way of thinking will end up adapting his way of thinking to his way of life, thus killing his moral conscience.

The story of the execution of John the Baptist can serve as a parable to illustrate or exemplify the death of Herod’s moral conscience. Herod acknowledged that John the Baptist was right, that taking and living with his brother’s wife was morally wrong. John was Herod’s moral conscience that could speak but could not act and therefore was imprisoned. Herod liked to listen to the truth but lacked the will to put it into practice; hence he went about his life without deciding until the circumstances of life decided for him.
 
Collective psychosis
The death of moral conscience, which regulates our life and guides and judges our everyday acts, leads to psychosis. A psychotic is a cold and cruel person without feelings, and who can hurt or be a bystander to the sufferings of others without compassion; in severe cases, a psychotic can escalate to torture and kill without the least sense of guilt or remorse. The lack of an accusatory moral conscience, common in many people today, could be diagnosed as a chronic collective psychosis.

‘I have no sins’, this is what we hear in the confessional nowadays. Because our lives are focused on the distant, and not on the near, we see the speck in our neighbour’s eye and not the log that is in our own. Our conscience, which distinguishes us from the rest of the living beings that inhabit this planet, and which is the result of an evolution that lasted five million years, is not always there to help us. Much of our behaviour, what we say, what we do and even much of what we think, work independently of our will, that is, we live on auto-pilot for the most part throughout our day.

Two friends upon meeting after some time without seeing each other, said one to the other, “I was told that you sold your old car to our friend Anthony for an exorbitant price, the car was worth much less than what you had asked for, you cheated the poor man”. “I cheated no one, what I did was a good business deal,” answered the seller. Saddened, and shaking his head in disapproval, his friend said, “I see… But I know that you are a practicing Catholic, when you kneel for a confession, what do you tell the priest?” “To the priest,” the seller said, “I tell him my sins not my business transactions.”

“You just sprayed sulphur on those cabbages yesterday and it looks like you are going to sell them already, should you not wait because it is dangerous? “Don’t worry” said the farmer, “I am not the one who is going to be eating them” – In our world the personal or collective profit is a principle that is placed above all else including the wellness of the public. This man may not eat these cabbages, but he does consume other agricultural produce that are grown and treated in the same manner just like the food that is produced industrially. When profit is placed above the health of the public no one wins; everybody loses.

The same is true of tax evasion, a sin that in my thirty-one year of priesthood I have never heard anyone mention in the confessional. Apparently or in the short term, whoever evades wins, keeping more money in his pockets, but in reality or in the long term, everybody loses, the evader included.

The sacrament of self-examination
The sacrament of penance, or confession, is in itself an exercise of self-examination. Only few people use it and of those who do, many do it out of routine or to observe the precept of the Church that exhorts Catholics to confess and receive the Holy Communion at least once a year during the Easter season. This is not done, therefore, out of necessity or for spiritual growth, but out of obligation.

And because it is done out of obligation and routine, when the penitents kneel in front of the confessor, they do not know what to say and resort to reciting a long-winded and often repeated list: to kill I did not kill, to steal I did not steal etc. For as hard as I try to scrutinize, without having the morbid curiosity of certain old confessors, I cannot decipher any personal sins and oftentimes what I hear are the sins of others, of the husband, the children, the in-laws and daughters-in-law, mothers-in-law etc.; how many times I had to stop the penitent from rambling on and remind him or her that I cannot forgive the sins of others but only his or her own…

I compare our moral consciousness to the sieves that were once used to sift and purify flour, by removing impurities which were the bran used to feed the hens, leaving behind the white flour used for baking.   The finer and smaller the mesh size of the sieves, the purer and whiter the resulting flour.

The moral consciences of many people nowadays are too lax; the mesh of their “sieves” is too course, or so filled with holes that the sifting action lets everything pass through thus retaining no impurities. It is therefore not true that they have not committed any sins because they have, but they are unaware of doing so because their conscience did not accuse them nor did it retain the sins. The righteous, says the Bible, sin seven times a day; seven being the perfect number meaning that one sins many times. So if a righteous person sees himself as a sinner, then who are we to say that we are not…

To drown in guilt like Judas
In the antipodes of the lax conscience, lie the scrupulous conscience; the one that cannot free itself from guilt.

One day a woman went to her parish priest and revealed to him that God often appeared to her. The incredulous pastor, in order to confirm the truthfulness of these apparitions or ironically to be amused at the expense of the lady, gave her permission to ask God to tell her his sins, thinking to himself, only God knows my sins, and if she tells me some of them then I will have to believe in these apparitions. The lady, taking seriously the proposal of the pastor without realizing the irony, went home. After few days have passed she came back to see the priest, the latter with an air of mockery asked, “So did God come back and reappear to you?” “Yes He did, Father,” she answered. “And did you ask Him about my sins?” “Indeed I did, Father,” she said. “And so what did God say?” inquired the priest. “With respect to your sins, Father, God told me that He had already forgotten them.”

There is no misery that is greater than the Divine Mercy. God forgives us and forgets, He turns the page which is something that we do not do easily. God knows us better than we know ourselves, loves us more than we love ourselves, and even in cases of healthy self-esteem, He also forgives us much more readily than we forgive ourselves.

At the end of a fratricide war between the Hindus and the Muslims, during the independence process of India, a Hindu went to Gandhi to see if he could help him get rid of his guilt. He told the story of how one day, during the war, he entered the house of a Muslim family where he saw a Muslim woman breastfeeding her baby, he snatched the baby from the mother’s arms and hurled it against the walls. The image of the baby smashed against the wall with its blood flowing out, he said, “follows me wherever I go, I am living in hell…” Gandhi, to help him rid of his guilt, proposed that he adopts a Muslim baby, from the many that were left orphaned by the war, and to bring him up in the Muslim faith.

In my thirty-one of ministry, there have been quite a few women eighty plus years of age who are still confessing obsessively, again and again, the abortion that they had committed when they were teenagers. The scrupulous believe more in a vengeful God, the human way, than in a God of love. It is an offense against God not to believe in His pardon, when God can do nothing else…

…erasing the record that stood against us with its legal demands. He set this aside, nailing it to the cross. (Col. 2:14)

God forgives and forgets, as St. Paul suggests, He destroys the invoice of our debt so not to be reminded of it; it is us who by our nature cannot forgive nor forget. The purgatory, of which the Bible does not speak directly, was created by God not because He needs us to expiate our guilt, but because we need to atone for our own guilt.

To recognize and to cry over the mistake like Peter
(Before the miraculous catch of fish) when Simon Peter saw it, he fell down at Jesus’ knees, saying, ‘Go away from me, Lord, for I am a sinful man!’ (Lk. 5:8)

“In medio vírtus” – Between the two extremes, the lax and the scrupulous moral conscience, stands out Peter’s moral conscience, which is neither lax nor scrupulous. Peter has before God the right attitude that all sinners should have; he acknowledges his own sinfulness by seeing the power of God manifested in Jesus Christ with respect to the miraculous catch of fish.

The episode of the miraculous catch proves that it was not the denial of the Master, a sin equivalent to the betrayal of Judas, which gave Peter the consciousness of being a sinner; Peter always had the awareness that before God there is no one who is not a sinner.

In conclusion, since what we are and what we are called to be never match, a life that is not routinely examined, as the Greek philosopher Socrates says, is not worth living; therefore, we can only improve and grow as persons through self-knowledge, that is, to know what is wrong with our own selves. Just like the way a GPS operates, we can only know the road to where we want to go after knowing where we are at the present moment of our journey; as well as in medicine, we cannot be cured of a disease that has not yet been diagnosed.
                                            Fr. Jorge Amaro, IMC